Monday, October 25, 2021

Proposal: No blank Realtors

Withdrawn - Adminned by Trapdoorspyder

Adminned at 26 Oct 2021 21:25:51 UTC

In “Estate Agents”, add a subrule named “Unblank Realtors”:

If a Realtor has not done so, they may Get A Reroll and set their Charisma to 3.

If no other Realtor had done so, any Realtor may Unblank Realtors as a Atomic Action after 28th October, 2021 1200 UTC and perform the following:

* For each Realtor whose Charisma is 1 to 3, roll 4DICE4 for them and set their Charisma to the value rolled.
* Repeal Unblank Realtors.

Hey, I do want more Realtors to be Charismatic.

Comments

Chiiika: she/her

25-10-2021 16:00:56 UTC

As per if you should reroll at all, here includes a cumulative probability of the output of 4d4:

#,%
4,100
5,99.609375
6,98.046875
7,94.140625
8,86.328125
9,74.21875
10,58.59375
11,41.40625
12,25.78125
13,13.671875
14,5.859375
15,1.953125
16,0.390625

Trapdoorspyder: he/him

25-10-2021 16:59:10 UTC

Can you please add a clarification that prevents infinite rerolls?

Chiiika: she/her

25-10-2021 17:07:11 UTC

No, you can only reroll once, the actual mechanism to reroll is in the Unblank Realtors action

Chiiika: she/her

25-10-2021 17:09:17 UTC

But for safety reasons, added a clause that make Unblank Realtors happen only once

Chiiika: she/her

25-10-2021 17:11:36 UTC

The Get A Reroll action only flags you for Reroll, the Unblank Realtors is what makes you reroll

Chiiika: she/her

25-10-2021 17:18:10 UTC

But thank you Spider, there is another loophole that I’ve overlooked:

In the original version if a Realtor rolls and Gets a Reroll, their Charisma stays at 1 which is ambiguous if they’ve done the action outline in the if clause a paragraph above

Changing the value set by Getting a Reroll to 2 resolves this ambiguity, as they can’t activate the if clause a para above, and also 4d4 simply can’t output 2.

Chiiika: she/her

25-10-2021 17:33:40 UTC

There’s another pathway to create a non modified Get a Reroll (Roll any number, Get a Reroll and Do Bad Choices), fixed as well.

redtara: they/them

25-10-2021 18:00:58 UTC

Anyone unidling/joining after Oct 28 is gonna be stuck at one.

Chiiika: she/her

25-10-2021 18:45:26 UTC

I don’t think I can address these at the same time for complexity reasons

Chiiika: she/her

25-10-2021 18:46:27 UTC

Tbh I’d set the default to be 4d4 but removing the removing part also works, tho setting the default to 4d4 makes the whole section more readable

Chiiika: she/her

25-10-2021 18:47:47 UTC

But tho you’re right, I can address the whole thing in another proposal. Modified.

Josh: Observer he/they

25-10-2021 19:53:35 UTC

against I’d rather wait until we know what charisma does.

pokes:

25-10-2021 20:21:16 UTC

against

Brendan: he/him

25-10-2021 21:58:45 UTC

for I like this solution.

TyGuy6:

25-10-2021 23:42:01 UTC

for

Chiiika: she/her

26-10-2021 05:46:25 UTC

Josh I literally locked the Charisma thing, unless this is done nobody could’ve pass a use for Charisma

TyGuy6:

26-10-2021 05:55:51 UTC

I’m already feeling more motivated to make Charisma matter during the period before the Unblanking. The window won’t be very long, but we could pass a decent proposal by that time.

Raven1207: he/they

26-10-2021 13:10:22 UTC

against

Lulu: she/her

26-10-2021 13:42:05 UTC

against

Chiiika: she/her

26-10-2021 17:48:14 UTC

I don’t even know the reasoning for everyone redcrossing that.

Chiiika: she/her

26-10-2021 19:32:41 UTC

against Withdrawn as there is some players who wait on something that never come to happen, let’s axe it