Sunday, June 18, 2017

Proposal: No Disguising The Past

Timed out 7-2 with 3 DEFs. Enacted by card.

Adminned at 20 Jun 2017 15:29:37 UTC

If the Expedition Leader does not have a valid FOR vote on this proposal, it does nothing instead.

Make a new rule “Unmasked” with the text:

After a DoV or DoA has passed the Expedition Leader makes an “Unmasked” post in a timely manner containing the following information:
The backgrounds of each Explorer along with the date and time they received those backgrounds.
If an Explorer used a secret power (such as the spy’s power), include what time and date they used it at and what information they received from using such a power.

posted by card at 18 Jun 2017 05:41:00 UTC Comments (16)

Comments

Madrid:

18-06-2017 10:38:28 UTC

for

Cpt_Koen:

18-06-2017 12:07:56 UTC

imperial It’s not very polite calling the Expedition Leader an “it”!

Kevan: he/him

18-06-2017 14:49:49 UTC

imperial

Sinq:

18-06-2017 15:27:33 UTC

for

Madrid:

18-06-2017 19:46:45 UTC

“If the Expedition Leader does not have a valid FOR vote on this proposal, it does nothing instead.”-> the ELeader could just Veto if they can’t do this anyways without that clause but tomahtos tomatoes.

card:

19-06-2017 04:01:27 UTC

Yeah but if the Expedition Leader doesn’t vote at all we don’t want to give them extra work.

Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: he/they

19-06-2017 09:57:28 UTC

against

orkboi:

19-06-2017 15:42:27 UTC

imperial

Madrid:

19-06-2017 15:57:28 UTC

@card: ah, true

Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: he/they

19-06-2017 17:00:11 UTC

But, what if they wish to not comment, i.e. security council’s difference between veto and against.

Madrid:

19-06-2017 20:49:16 UTC

@PSS: If Sphinx doesn’t comment then nothing at all happens, that’s the trick.

pokes:

20-06-2017 00:14:57 UTC

imperial

card:

20-06-2017 07:19:32 UTC

So is anyone going to propose something else, or are we done with this dynasty?
Weekends don’t usually seem to bring this much of a hiccup in proposals.

Kevan: he/him

20-06-2017 07:54:35 UTC

Might be that people were waiting for the new week’s Hints to be posted, after a week with two or more successful Conspiracies.

I’m a bit worried that the “Cthulhu rises, nobody wins!” Cultist mechanic means that there’s actually not much incentive for individual Cultists to try and win (or do anything at all). And that since it looks easier for Cultists to coordinate than for Scholars, Cultists are likely to increase in number.

pokes:

20-06-2017 10:37:32 UTC

CoV against

Sphinx:

20-06-2017 12:53:27 UTC

for

I think I tracked everything important for this proposal.