Wednesday, November 14, 2007

Call for Judgment: Non-Retroactive Graveyard Shift

Fails after 96 hours
—Hix

Adminned at 18 Nov 2007 13:55:56 UTC

Hypothetically speaking, under the current ruleset (ignoring the “Graveyard Shift” proposal), the original Night Watchman should retain his position (and so be entitled to receive information from the Mayor) even if he dies.

Let us hypothesize for a moment that this situation has happened.

If this CfJ passes, the Mayor shall provide to the original Night Watchman, if any, all information that the Mayor has provided to any purported successor “Night Watchman” in that capacity, and shall continue to do so until “Graveyard Shift” passes.

Comments

Kevan: he/him

14-11-2007 14:57:37 UTC

This is unfair if the werewolves somehow knew that a dead Watchman had definitely been replaced, and were playing under the assumption that killing a Watchman was enough to stop them from gathering too much information.

Was anyone assuming that a dead Watchman was still the Watchman? Nobody has contacted me privately about this, and I don’t remember it coming up in the weblog.

Brendan: he/him

14-11-2007 14:57:54 UTC

Hmm, this seems less like a “differing interpretation” of the rules than an attempt to create a new one.  Assuming Kevan’s retroactive-legality proposal passes,  against

Chivalrybean:

14-11-2007 15:26:59 UTC

against

BobTHJ:

14-11-2007 16:03:40 UTC

against

Shadowclaw:

14-11-2007 16:10:36 UTC

against

Hix:

14-11-2007 16:33:12 UTC

against

Kevan: he/him

14-11-2007 16:56:43 UTC

against

Amnistar: he/him

14-11-2007 18:23:52 UTC

against

Elias IX:

14-11-2007 21:34:36 UTC

against

Darknight: he/him

14-11-2007 21:52:57 UTC

against