Tuesday, March 07, 2017

Proposal: Obsoleting Notes

Quorums 8-0. — Quirck

Adminned at 08 Mar 2017 21:02:25 UTC

In the rule 3.2 “Gamestate Tracking”, change “If no Organ has commented on it, or if the only comments on it begin with “Note:” and contain no voting icons, an official post may be altered or removed by its author;” to

An official post may be altered or removed by its author if it is less than six hours old and either no Organ has commented on it or all comments on it contain no voting icons;

Comments

Madrid:

07-03-2017 20:07:21 UTC

Note: I dunno, the notes thing makes it MUCH easier to know that we’re in “edit mode”. It’s very convenient imo, even more now that we’ve got so many people I believe.

derrick: he/him

07-03-2017 20:11:07 UTC

Note: On the other hand, this doesn’t require everyone to use good etiquette and say “Note” before every comment.

Oracular rufio:

07-03-2017 20:14:28 UTC

Note: Proposal age is shown in the sidebar.  I think it’s fine.  This also prevents editing the proposal with no comments at the last minute to say “I win” but I only know of one time when that happened.

card:

07-03-2017 20:16:38 UTC

Works for me for

Oracular rufio:

07-03-2017 20:52:34 UTC

for

pokes:

07-03-2017 20:58:30 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

07-03-2017 21:02:27 UTC

for Creates a potential surprise for official posts that use comments but not actual votes (like last dynasty’s remedy-takings), but this can be patched.

Viv:

07-03-2017 21:12:06 UTC

for

derrick: he/him

07-03-2017 21:31:12 UTC

for

Sphinx:

07-03-2017 22:02:34 UTC

for