Wednesday, February 20, 2013

Proposal: Outfield

Times out and fails 2-6. -RaichuKFM

Adminned at 21 Feb 2013 17:40:23 UTC

If there exists a rule entitled “Complications”, change its text to read:

No rule may specify a victory condition that cannot possibly ever be achieved by any Honourable Member; any proposal that seeks to enact such a rule may be marked as illegal at any time by an admin.

If there does not exist a rule entitled “Complications”, enact a new rule entitled “Complications” with the above text.

Not just about names. Every Honourable Members should theoretically be able to, at some point, achieve the victory condition.
(Incorrectly Adminned by RaichuKFM and near-immediately fixed. Old admin text: Can’t be enacted and fails 2-7. -RaichuKFM)

Comments

Skju:

20-02-2013 01:40:00 UTC

I didn’t want to worry about Deliberations passing and so forth.

Larrytheturtle:

20-02-2013 01:43:25 UTC

for

RaichuKFM: she/her

20-02-2013 02:32:06 UTC

for

Klisz:

20-02-2013 05:19:40 UTC

for

Spitemaster:

20-02-2013 06:32:35 UTC

for

Purplebeard:

20-02-2013 07:53:52 UTC

against “Cannot possibly ever” doesn’t mean much when we can change the game pretty much whenever and however we please through proposals. Even something like “The Honourable Member called Purplebeard has achieved victory” could easily apply to anyone after two name-changes.

Josh: Observer he/they

20-02-2013 08:18:15 UTC

against “cannot possibly ever be achieved by any Honourable Member” has a dual meaning; it can mean what you intend it to, but it can equally legitimately mean that if a single Honourable Member can achieve it then it’s legal.

RaichuKFM: she/her

20-02-2013 11:11:44 UTC

against CoV per Joshlebeard.

Larrytheturtle:

20-02-2013 16:30:57 UTC

against cov

Josh: Observer he/they

20-02-2013 17:47:58 UTC

Joshlebeard ^_^

MurphEngineer:

21-02-2013 15:40:03 UTC

against

RaichuKFM: she/her

21-02-2013 20:40:10 UTC

against  arrow Because we’re preserving “Over 9000”.

Skju:

21-02-2013 23:52:25 UTC

against Alright. Self Kill.