Sunday, June 08, 2014

Proposal: Proposal: Mysterious Evil Sorcerer

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 09 Jun 2014 10:48:34 UTC

The Mysterious Evil Sorcerer is a beast. She has a fortitude of 13. Her goal is obtain a unique item called the Phoenix Wand. The Mysterious Evil Sorcerer’s behavior is to reduce a random knight’s gold by 2. The Mysterious Evil Sorcerer also randomly gives out a quiver to a random knight.

Comments

Sam:

09-06-2014 00:55:41 UTC

for

TheChosenOne:

09-06-2014 01:16:59 UTC

no. quivers are already way way too common. imperial

TheChosenOne:

09-06-2014 01:18:05 UTC

edit: actually, quivers are just OP, not common.
The pheonix wand does not exist and thus her goal will never be achieved.

Kevan: Oracle he/him

09-06-2014 07:46:13 UTC

If this used to say “pheonix wand” and you changed it, I’m afraid that’s not allowed (per Rule 3.2, “If no Knight has commented on it, an official post may be altered or removed by its author; otherwise this can only be done as allowed by the Ruleset.”) - it’s kind of common sense, otherwise you could add “Rainbowkitten08 wins!” to your proposal just before it got voted through.

The Newbie Guide is worth a read; we should probably add a line about not changing proposals if it’s not already in there.

against because this doesn’t explicitly create a rule and “very often” doesn’t mean anything.

Purplebeard:

09-06-2014 08:13:23 UTC

against I’ve gone ahead and reverted the illegal edit. The nonexistence of the Phoenix Wand wouldn’t have been a problem anyway; we’ve already had the Lady of the Lake searching for Excalibur. There’s nothing stopping us from adding the item later, or just keeping the Motive unobtainable.

ayesdeeef:

09-06-2014 15:57:58 UTC

imperial
The format is so… not right.

Sam:

09-06-2014 17:35:51 UTC

against
Ohh! I’m sorry. I kind of thought it was a new beast.

Kevan: Oracle he/him

09-06-2014 17:48:30 UTC

It’s obvious what you meant, but Nomic is all about specifying exactly what’s going to happen to the ruleset.