Sunday, April 17, 2011

Proposal: Record Keeper

Fails at 2-13. -Purplebeard

Adminned at 19 Apr 2011 01:44:46 UTC

If the rule “Officials” exists add the following sub-rule “Record Keeper” to it:

Duties: Makes sure that the Ruleset on the wiki is updated when necessary.

Useful, eh?

Comments

Bucky:

04-17-2011 21:16:40 UTC

against .
1)Enact a proposal
2)Oust the record keeper
3)Make the proposal’s rule changes

lilomar:

04-17-2011 21:31:28 UTC

Also, this is already the job of all Admins.

Darknight: HE/HIM

04-17-2011 22:12:41 UTC

against

lilomar:

04-17-2011 22:18:41 UTC

against oh, right, forgot to actually vote…

Travis:

04-17-2011 22:27:55 UTC

for

scshunt:

04-17-2011 22:45:05 UTC

against

Kevan: HE/HIM

04-17-2011 22:46:27 UTC

against Bucky’s argument can be undercut by “I pledge to make sure that the ruleset is updated by encouraging all admins to do their jobs, well done admins”, but this does seem a bit meaningless, really.

spikebrennan:

04-18-2011 00:15:13 UTC

against

Josh: GAIA HE/HIM

04-18-2011 06:14:58 UTC

against

Purplebeard:

04-18-2011 11:48:57 UTC

against

WildCard:

04-18-2011 14:09:25 UTC

against

Ely:

04-18-2011 15:59:45 UTC

against

Roujo:

04-18-2011 16:51:39 UTC

against

ais523:

04-18-2011 18:37:01 UTC

against Could be a good idea with similar mechanics in a different nomic, but as it is, is both trivial and easily scammed. Perhaps a variant that had to ensure that all ruleset/gamestate updates were legal, within a certain time after they happened (24 hours? 48 hours?), could be useful; a sort of catch-mistakes-made-by-others office. I fear, though, that it might encourage people to make mistakes deliberately in an attempt to catch people out, which would be pretty bad for the game.

Subrincinator:

04-18-2011 18:45:36 UTC

against

Florw:

04-18-2011 18:58:27 UTC

Travis: Admin Herder deadline is within 48 hours in regards to the proposal, “Record Keeper”.

Chivalrybean:

04-19-2011 05:41:07 UTC

against