Tuesday, January 26, 2010

Proposal: Restrain Your Enthusiasm

Reached quorum 15 votes to 1. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 27 Jan 2010 16:30:11 UTC

In Rule 2.2, replace “Terrified, Asleep” with “Terrified, Arrested, Asleep” in both places where it appears.

To the first bulleted list in Rule 2.2, add:-

  • If a Guest is Arrested, they cannot become anything other than Arrested.

To the list of actions in Rule 2.6, add:-

  • Free a named Guest (known as the Target) that they share a room with. Upon taking this Action, if the Target is present in the same room as the Guest freeing them, if there are fewer than two non-Dormant Guests in that room (not including the Guest taking the freeing action), and if the Target is Restrained, the Target becomes Healthy.

Add a subrule to Rule 2.4, called “Arrest”:-

If a Guest becomes Arrested, they are removed from the house for police questioning. Their Location value becomes “Cell” (this is a valid Location, but does not count as a Room).

The police have only a limited amount of cells and patience. If four Guests have become Arrested during the course of the game, further Guests may not become Arrested.

If a rule “Deathly Quiet” exists, replace “if their Status is currently Dead” with “if their Status is currently Dead or Arrested”.

Straight reproposal of Loosening the Restraints, fixed so that you can only perform the Freeing action on Guests who are actually Restrained.

Comments

redtara: they/them

26-01-2010 11:51:23 UTC

against Per bloodthirst.

Kevan: he/him

26-01-2010 11:55:27 UTC

Per what?

spikebrennan:

26-01-2010 15:22:46 UTC

for

spikebrennan:

26-01-2010 15:23:06 UTC

I think that he’s just being spiteful, on account of being dead.

Uvthenfuv:

26-01-2010 15:47:24 UTC

for

redtara: they/them

26-01-2010 16:34:02 UTC

No, I think that killing an Arrested could be fun. You know, quiet them before they talk.

Kevan: he/him

26-01-2010 16:39:43 UTC

That would actually be entirely possible, if the lights went out during a Crisis to arrest someone, and a murderer decided they want to intervene.

redtara: they/them

26-01-2010 16:56:58 UTC

Yes, it’s possible beforehand.

Kevan: he/him

26-01-2010 17:09:04 UTC

It’s also possible afterwards with a Crisis of “kill the guy in the cell, this takes precedence over the rule restricting the change of status from Arrested to Dead”.

Being Arrested would be functionally identical to being Dead, though, at least for now - it seemed more polite and thematic than dinner party guests having to kill their suspect (although they can do that as well, if they like). I’m not sure why this is a reason to vote against, or why it’s less bloodthirsty than politely tying and untying people all game.

Ornithopter:

26-01-2010 19:09:59 UTC

for
I can’t think of any tactical reason to kill someone who’s been arrested.

Purplebeard:

26-01-2010 19:13:20 UTC

for

TrumanCapote:

26-01-2010 19:58:16 UTC

for

Nausved:

26-01-2010 21:24:26 UTC

imperial

Roujo: he/him

26-01-2010 22:56:55 UTC

for @Ornithopter: Good point ^^

Anonyman:

26-01-2010 23:39:28 UTC

for

Darknight: he/him

27-01-2010 00:10:40 UTC

for

redtara: they/them

27-01-2010 02:24:28 UTC

So they don’t talk.

Thrawn:

27-01-2010 03:48:55 UTC

for

Thrawn:

27-01-2010 04:13:46 UTC

for

digibomber:

27-01-2010 05:47:44 UTC

for

Excalabur:

27-01-2010 07:09:37 UTC

for

Oze:

27-01-2010 16:12:45 UTC

for

Keba:

27-01-2010 19:39:20 UTC

for