Tuesday, June 04, 2019

Proposal: Self-Promotion 1.1

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 05 Jun 2019 13:41:07 UTC

Add to the rule “Civic Titles”:

If an Architect’s Site meets the criteria for one or more Civil Titles, they may update the Moon Sites page to display the relevant Civil Title/s next to their name.
This is called ‘claiming’.

Add to the rule “Civic Titles”:

An Architect holds a Civil Title if their Site meets the criteria for that Title, and if they have claimed that Title.

Add to the rule “Civic Titles”:

An Architect may claim a Civil Title which is held by another Architect.

I broke it up into three rules to make it easier to agree to one part and object to another, if necessary.


Kevan: City he/him

04-06-2019 08:03:24 UTC

The and-statement of the second bit slightly undermines the rest - that sometimes the wiki will be wrong when it says “Farsight: Cool House”, if Farsight’s base no longer (without anyone noticing) qualifies as the Cool House.

for otherwise, though.


04-06-2019 14:14:43 UTC

Hm, you’re right, but then if that clause wasn’t there, we would be left with the passive statement:

“An Architect holds a Civil Title if their Site meets the criteria for that Title.”

Which means that an Architect could hold the Title without having claimed it, because they haven’t noticed their Site meets the criteria.

Kevan: City he/him

04-06-2019 15:21:39 UTC

Having just the other half of the clause would work: if you’ve claimed a title you get to keep it until someone else claims it from you (even if your site doesn’t meet its criteria any more).


04-06-2019 15:48:01 UTC

Yeah okay, if this proposal is enacted we could alter it then.


05-06-2019 10:30:19 UTC



05-06-2019 13:34:26 UTC



05-06-2019 13:39:00 UTC

against I’ve changed my mind, Ideal Dome Exhibition is better.