Wednesday, February 24, 2016

Proposal: Show of Force

Can’t pass with less than quorum not voting against, and fails 1-5. -RaichuKFM

Adminned at 26 Feb 2016 19:32:22 UTC

Create a rule “Show of Force” with the following text:

Whenever an Orc casts a vote on a votable matter other than a CfJ, they may spend any quantity of Warriors. If they do so then they may append the words “Show of Force:X” to their EVC, where X is the number of Warriors thus spent . If an Orc who has spent Warriors on a vote changes that vote then the Warriors are lost; it is neither returned to them nor is it transferred to the new vote.

When a proposal is resolved, its eligibility for resolution (i.e. whether or not the number of votes cast equal or exceed quorum) is calculated ignoring Warriors. Any Warriors attached to an EVC is added to the counts FOR and AGAINST for the purposes of determining whether or not the votable matter has passed or failed. No proposal may pass if only one player has an EVC FOR, regardless of the amount of Warriors appended to EVCs on that proposal.



25-02-2016 05:14:59 UTC

Feels wrong to me.  against


25-02-2016 11:18:09 UTC



25-02-2016 16:11:35 UTC


Brendan: he/him

25-02-2016 17:12:26 UTC

against I respect the safeguards here, but even if there aren’t any scams to pull off, it still seems like it’s allowing the most powerful players to create more rules that favor themselves.

RaichuKFM: she/her

25-02-2016 22:52:53 UTC

against I like the gall to port this of all things over, but an iffy fit with the flavor of gameplay, and consensus is against.

Also, reading it, I think it adds any Warriors in EVCs to both the FOR and AGAINST tallies? Just for posterity, in case it gets reposted.