Tuesday, May 23, 2017

Proposal: so very very cold . . .

Reaches quorum 7-0. Enacted by pokes.

Note we now have two rules titled “Supplies” so be sure to disambiguate in the future if a proposal touches a specific one.

Adminned at 24 May 2017 21:18:11 UTC

make a rule titled “Supplies” with the following text

If an Explorer has one or more Dog Sleds, they may change their camp to the camp with the nearest Latitude to their current camp by spending 1 supplies. They cannot take this action if they have zero or less supplies.

If “It’s cold out here!” has passed add the following text under “Supplies”

Explorers must spend 1 supplies each time they do an action which defined in rules that are Very Cold. Explorers must spend 1 supplies each time they do an action which defined in rules that are Extremely Cold. If an Explorer has zero or less supplies, they cannot take actions which are defined in rules that are Very Cold.

Comments

Sphinx:

23-05-2017 06:59:01 UTC

We need at least the nearest camp in one direction and the other, else we could get stuck in a loop.

I don’t know if the supply spending rule is explicit enough about spending two extra supplies. If I spend one extra, I can satisfy both the Very Cold and Extremely Cold parts with that.

Cuddlebeam:

23-05-2017 12:09:03 UTC

aaaand whipping out another green tick because this seems cool too for

Generally, more weight and thought/consideration behind making any GNDT/wiki-trackable modification seems good to me (hopefully its not too much weight though).

Less “cookie clicker” and more “chess”.

pokes:

23-05-2017 12:18:23 UTC

imperial

Matt:

23-05-2017 13:35:49 UTC

imperial

Publius Scribonius Scholasticus: he/they

24-05-2017 10:08:46 UTC

for

Cpt_Koen:

24-05-2017 15:53:06 UTC

for Though I would argue that we can change camp while spending just 1 supplies and satisfy both rules at once, because:

“Explorers must spend 1 supplies each time they do an action which defined in rules that are Very Cold.”

is not equivalent to:

“Explorers must spend 1 extra supplies each time they do an action which defined in rules that are Very Cold.”

Sphinx:

24-05-2017 19:52:56 UTC

Cpt_Koen: I agree, I don’t think the extremely cold part increases the price either, for the same reason. Should probably be fixed.

for