Monday, June 06, 2011

Proposal: Stealin’ your woods

Timed out 4-4.—Yoda
I would rather see this fail because I abstained than pass by 1 vote.

Adminned at 08 Jun 2011 12:33:07 UTC

Add the following text to the end of the Rule “Storage Space”:

When a Zombie destroys a Shed belonging to an active Farmer, the Farmer loses all their Wood and the Zombie’s Owner gains Wood equal to the amount lost.

Comments

Yoda:

06-06-2011 18:38:45 UTC

for Sure, why not?  Forces Farmers to more strategically place sheds.

SingularByte: he/him

06-06-2011 18:45:39 UTC

for

Purplebeard:

06-06-2011 19:58:25 UTC

for

Ely:

06-06-2011 21:32:35 UTC

against

BellEt:

06-06-2011 21:50:02 UTC

against seems harsh, maybe if it were HALF their wood

BellEt:

06-06-2011 21:50:30 UTC

against seems harsh, maybe if it were HALF their wood

BellEt:

06-06-2011 21:50:51 UTC

oops sorry about the double post

mideg:

06-06-2011 21:56:32 UTC

against I’d say something along the lines of a proportion of their wood according to their number of sheds.

Doesn’t seem to ‘logical’ to store all your wood in every shed. Especially when at the same time you can store wood without any sheds.

Bucky:

07-06-2011 00:41:22 UTC

mideg, each farmer can only have one shed at a time.

mideg:

07-06-2011 05:01:10 UTC

OK, completely didn’t think about it. Thanks for the hint.

Still, the second point holds, so at most half the wood should be the punishment…

aguydude:

07-06-2011 08:24:02 UTC

against for several reasons:

1.  Strategically place the shed? It has 10 defense.
2.  A player can safely remove their shed at will by planting over it.
3.  This rule seems unfair to those who’ve already placed their shed.

Galtori:

07-06-2011 20:53:22 UTC

Hmmm. . . I like the idea of the zombies owner getting the wood, but I don’t like how much wood would be given.
for
If it passes, I’ll make a proposal to fix how much wood would be taken.

Yoda:

08-06-2011 02:01:13 UTC

Also, I don’t know why you guys are so upset.  As it stands right now, even with the buff from the “Thriller” proposal, the only zombie that even has a chance at destroying a shed is a Bombie.

mideg:

08-06-2011 05:12:51 UTC

@Yoda: Well, if we do not expect that to change, this round will not be much fun.

Yoda:

08-06-2011 15:46:43 UTC

imperial The vote is too close, so I’m going to abstain.