Tuesday, June 14, 2011

Proposal: Stop And Smell The Roses

Reaches quorum, is trivial and passes at 10-0. -Purplebeard

Adminned at 16 Jun 2011 01:03:05 UTC

Throughout the Ruleset and the Gardening Compendium, change “Counterback Effect” to “Pheromone”.

Remove “Whenever attacked, ” from the Pheromone of the Cabbage, Potato and Watermelon [Juicy].

Change the Catatulip’s Pheromone to an Effect.

‘Counterback’ just sounds completely ridiculous to me. Lots of plants emit pheromones when grazed (or presumably when slashed to death by a zombie), so this is at least somewhat believable and on-theme. The other changes are just to remove misleading wording (counterback effects/pheromones only trigger if the crop is destroyed) and to make the Catatulip function as intended.

Comments

Ely:

14-06-2011 11:49:28 UTC

I don’t see any ambiguity, the Counterback effect triggers when the Crop is attacked.
against

Ely:

14-06-2011 11:49:40 UTC

Oh,  against trivial

Purplebeard:

14-06-2011 12:18:33 UTC

Rule ‘Planting’: “A seed may also have a Counterback Effect, which takes effect if a zombie destroys the crop.”

SingularByte: he/him

14-06-2011 12:50:33 UTC

for

Doctor29:

14-06-2011 14:38:55 UTC

for but definitely trivial

Yoda:

14-06-2011 14:49:38 UTC

for trivial

Ely: Counterback effects don’t trigger when the crop is attacked but when it’s destroyed, so the wording is misleading.

mideg:

14-06-2011 15:33:19 UTC

for trivial

Bucky:

14-06-2011 17:28:03 UTC

imperial trivial

aguydude:

14-06-2011 23:22:13 UTC

imperial Trivial

Winner:

15-06-2011 00:53:02 UTC

imperial Trivial

Florw:

15-06-2011 03:19:21 UTC

for

Ely:

15-06-2011 14:29:36 UTC

imperial CoV trivial