Sunday, February 08, 2009

Call for Judgment: Technically, C is true as well as B

Qourumed against.
-Amnistar

Adminned at 09 Feb 2009 16:51:29 UTC

Give Hix, Sparrow, and Rodlen one guess and 20 credits each.

Okay, so we know that B is the true answer.  However, based on information gained earlier in the dynasty…C is true too.  True due to a typo, but still true.  Some of you may remember the “All but one” incident.  I don’t think I need to say more.

Comments

Rodlen:

08-02-2009 17:03:54 UTC

If C isn’t true, then we have to assume that the “All but one” hint is true, invalidating other hints, making C true again…

Rodlen:

08-02-2009 17:04:06 UTC

for

Sparrow:

08-02-2009 17:07:39 UTC

for Exactly

Amnistar: he/him

08-02-2009 17:23:16 UTC

for

Clucky: he/him

08-02-2009 17:31:35 UTC

against Except the All but one thing isn’t a hint anymore, as it was changed.

Rodlen:

08-02-2009 17:32:32 UTC

It was given as a hint.  A later hint said it was not true.

Klisz:

08-02-2009 17:42:56 UTC

against

Kevan: he/him

08-02-2009 18:25:45 UTC

against The hint in question was retracted and corrected.

Sparrow:

08-02-2009 18:28:34 UTC

It says, “One of the hints that arthexis has given is false.”

That was definitely a hint that he “has given,” and it was false.

arthexis: he/him

08-02-2009 18:29:40 UTC

against Childish.

Darknight: he/him

08-02-2009 18:41:00 UTC

against

Hix:

08-02-2009 18:51:00 UTC

against The recent proposal clearly implied that exactly one of A, B, and C was true.  Those who chose B won, full stop.

Qwazukee:

08-02-2009 19:00:04 UTC

imperial

Qwazukee:

08-02-2009 19:01:00 UTC

Which, translated into useableness, =  against

Rodlen:

08-02-2009 20:29:05 UTC

Hmm…

So, basically, all hints we have recieved, according to the voting pattern here, are true, even the “all but one” hint?

Rodlen:

08-02-2009 20:29:25 UTC

Odd.

Well, I give up.

against CoV

Sparrow:

08-02-2009 20:30:42 UTC

@Rodlen: Just because the CfJ was shot down doesn’t mean it isn’t correct.

Rodlen:

08-02-2009 20:35:55 UTC

To quote Hix,

“The recent proposal clearly implied that exactly one of A, B, and C was true.  Those who chose B won, full stop. “

Amnistar: he/him

08-02-2009 20:37:22 UTC

against

Sparrow:

08-02-2009 20:39:04 UTC

against for speed

ais523:

09-02-2009 17:17:38 UTC

against