Proposal: That’s cool, but have you considered…
Unpopular, 1-5. Failed by JonathanDark.
Adminned at 22 May 2025 05:30:17 UTC
Create a subrule of Reviews, called “Feedback”, with the following text:
There is a publicly tracked list of Feedback, defaulting to empty. Feedback is a flavor text string of at most 500 characters, along with the name of the idle Drafter who created it and the name of a Drafter that it is meant for. Feedback may only be created by Idle Drafters, and may only be meant for non-Idle Drafters. Idle Drafters are not allowed to create multiple pieces of Feedback all meant for the same Drafter, though they are allowed to replace any of their previous Feedback with different Feedback, so long as it is still meant for the same Drafter. Feedback should include genuine feedback on the Plan of the Drafter it is meant for, as well as information as to whether or not the Idle Drafter who created the Feedback would be willing to unidle in order to join the Dynasty represented by the Plan. Feedback is not included in any calculations of Score.
As I suggested in the comments on the proposal “Up to the Jury”, a way for Idle Drafters to add Reviews without being able to influence scoring (as Feedback does not have scores). We can change this later, but for now, it seems like a safe bet to keep Idle Drafters from being able to increase or decrease anyone’s Scores.
Josh: Capital he/they