Proposal: The Maxim of Quantity
Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.
Adminned at 15 Mar 2017 17:26:04 UTC
Add a new rule to the Appendix called “The Maxim of Quantity” as follows:
The ruleset is assumed to follow Grice’s Maxim of Quantity, that is, that it must be as informative as possible, giving as much information as needed and no more. Specifically, a clause with “may” specifies the limits of an action that may be performed (“may collect three items” does not allow for an interpretation of “may collect any number of items, including three”, but only the meaning “may collect only three items”) and it cannot be interpreted to mean that abiding by the limitation is optional unless “may” is followed by “choose to”.
To put a stop to Cuddlebeam’s shenanigans.
Madrid:
This would mean that the entire ruleset is invalidated when I’m drunk af (or in some other state of reduced intellect) because it doesn’t have enough simple terms for me to understand (which I need in order for the ruleset to be informative, and its entirely possible to describe the ruleset in really simple terms).
That or the “is assumed” and “as needed” isn’t referring to the assumptions and necessities of the Organs, in which case I could just ignore the rule entirely because its not referring to me (nor any other Organ? I dont think it would be functional like that, unless the ruleset itself has needs and assumptions like people).