Call for Judgment: The Sketch Where The Henchman Objects To Being Given Ambiguous Instructions
Timed out 1 vote to 4. Failed by Kevan.
Adminned at 15 Feb 2023 08:52:18 UTC
If the CfJ “HWU2OFOOuW4” has been enacted, this CfJ has no further effect. If the CfJ “HWU2OFOOuW4” has not been enacted, fail it.
In the rule “Heat”, replace “transfer 0.1 Heat from the Villager with the most Heat in their Location to themselves” with:-
transfer 0.1 Heat from the Villager with the most Heat in their Location (if only a single such a Villager exists) to themselves
A plainer counter-CfJ to the other, asking the straight question of whether there’s a consensus view that Brendan was wrong to read “the Villager with the most Heat” as “any of the Villagers who have the most Heat”, and that we should - for now - just clarify the rule to how the majority were interpreting it. The question of whether Huddling should work differently is worth asking, but separately.
Josh: he/they
I like Brendan’s version and see no reason to faff around with a multi-stage process to enact it. Sure, by the book it should have been a proposal, but it wasn’t and it’s up for a vote so I’m not sure why were creating a cottage industry around this.