Sunday, April 02, 2023

Proposal: The Stonecrusher 5000

Timed out 4 votes to 3. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 04 Apr 2023 11:09:55 UTC

In the rule “The Quarry”, remove everything after the first sentence.

To the end of the “Move On” atomic action, add a step:-

* If the Quarry has at least as much Stone as five times the number of Engineers: give each Engineer 5 Stone and reduce the amount of Stone in the Quarry by five times the number of Engineers.

We’ve changed the compulsory hourly count to a compulsory daily check, but I suspect that people will still sometimes forget to do this, invalidating their actions. And the daily action DICE2 grind has already been flagged as “mostly pointless”.

So this keeps the finite Quarry, but simplifies its output to a single delivery for each new Building.

Comments

jjm3x3: he/him

02-04-2023 13:34:23 UTC

I think it’s mostly pointless because we haven’t been building. I like the randomness on the mining action and I like the <href a=https://blognomic.com/archive/local_213#comments >idea some time ago</href> there being some game state where not everyone can mine

Lulu: she/her

02-04-2023 15:17:59 UTC

for

jjm3x3: he/him

02-04-2023 16:26:42 UTC

against

JonathanDark: Publisher he/him

03-04-2023 05:37:26 UTC

against

Josh: he/they

03-04-2023 09:42:29 UTC

against

Kevan: he/him

03-04-2023 10:52:57 UTC

We’re almost unanimously voting to invalidate all progress on the DICE2 mining action and just set everyone to the same 10 Stone, but we still want to carry on rolling DICE2 every day after that?

Josh: he/they

03-04-2023 11:07:19 UTC

I guess at a certain point we might as well just give everyone an infinite amount of conceptual stone and make Stone the same as Wood.

Kevan: he/him

03-04-2023 14:34:45 UTC

Stone seems interesting as a rarer, heavier resource which can significantly shore up or unbalance the tower. It’s just the way we gain it that I think could use an overhaul.

The rule right now is that to gain Stone you have to check the wiki history to see if anyone has Eroded the Quarry recently (bearing in mind they might have done so without mentioning it in the edit summary), then Erode the Quarry if they haven’t, then roll DICE2 to see how much Stone you get. If you get the first part wrong then your Mining is invalid, and you yourself acknowledge that this effort is better avoided. And if you forget to take the action every single day of the dynasty, or happen to roll lower dice than your opponents, them’s the breaks.

Josh: he/they

03-04-2023 14:44:47 UTC

Sure, I don’t disagree that the current situation is broken. I just don’t think that a piecemeal, salami-slicing repeal is the right approach to fixing it, when a full rethink could do better.

I mean, this proposal is tantamount to “divide the current amount of stone by the number of players, rounded down; give each player that amount of Stone and set that amount as the default amount of Stone for new players”. Why skip the step?

Kevan: he/him

03-04-2023 15:51:36 UTC

Not sure if limiting Stone to a certain amount per player per Building is better or worse than giving it out all in one go - it’s probably more interesting that someone might run out of Stone within an individual round.

Brendan: he/him

03-04-2023 18:57:55 UTC

for

Habanero:

04-04-2023 02:06:30 UTC

for