I don’t like this one so much - it just gives people random reasons to lynch/murder people who otherwise have no reason to be killed (either for the humans or the werewolves).

It’d be cool if a drunk werewolf was unable to attack properly, or might reveal itself as a werewolf. Could also have similar negative effects on other professions, such as Night Watchman and Doctor, makes them unable to do their job as well. I’d like weekly better. Daily is a bit strong. 

i think a drunk person being killed should award NO acuity points—it’s an easy target.

It’s a cruel ability, but giving people the option to adopt and use a cruel ability is good for the game.

If I get a tankard, under rule 2.2, can’t I just hand it back to the Beer Seller? 

I think its good. Its cruel too, but would the villagers all decide to kill each other? i think a villager who repeatedly wanted drunk people killed would end up being killed. or the beer seller would be targeted. I also think chivalrybean has a very good idea and that should be implemented.

Hmm… Well, I do like that, unlike Mafia, if things keep going the way they are, everyone will have something to do, because if mafia, unless you have a ‘key’ role, what you can do is pretty limited. I think I’d vote FOR this is it was limited to at most weekly, or minimum only during Day or Night.

its ok but it could use some changes

cov—hockeyruler makes a good point, and we can always alter it later to merge in chivalrybean’s ideas

I think it adds to the game