Saturday, October 29, 2011

Proposal: Why just Dynastic?

Passes 12-9-1 after 48 hours with more FOR than AGAINST votes
“southpointingchariot, ChronosPhaenon, ais523, Bucky, amnistar, Pavitra, arthexis, Spitemaster, Ienpaw III, Flurie” is not a list of players, so no one gets SP
—arthexis

Adminned at 31 Oct 2011 11:55:42 UTC

REPRESENTING: southpointingchariot, ChronosPhaenon, ais523, Bucky, amnistar, Pavitra, arthexis, Spitemaster, Ienpaw III, Flurie

In the rule “Involuntary Representation Service” replace “Dynastic Proposals” with “Proposals”

posted by Amnistar at 29 Oct 2011 18:29:41 UTC Comments (30)

Comments

southpointingchariot:

29-10-2011 18:34:13 UTC

for

ChronosPhaenon:

29-10-2011 18:34:26 UTC

for

scshunt:

29-10-2011 18:47:17 UTC

against

Bucky:

29-10-2011 18:54:32 UTC

for

Murphy:

29-10-2011 18:59:15 UTC

for

ais523:

29-10-2011 19:12:35 UTC

for

Pavitra:

29-10-2011 19:14:22 UTC

for

omd:

29-10-2011 19:37:20 UTC

against

The amount of Representation is getting silly.

arthexis: he/him

29-10-2011 21:04:40 UTC

for

Shadowclaw:

29-10-2011 22:23:37 UTC

against per comex.

Ornithopter:

29-10-2011 23:40:56 UTC

against

Ornithopter:

29-10-2011 23:47:46 UTC

Ienpw’s name is misspelled in the list of representatives.

Amnistar: he/him

29-10-2011 23:48:39 UTC

You’re just jealous you’re not listed Comex.  It’s okay, I understand.

Also, sorry Ienpw, no SP for you :(

Spitemaster:

30-10-2011 02:01:13 UTC

for

lazerchik:

30-10-2011 02:26:35 UTC

for

flurie:

30-10-2011 03:38:26 UTC

for

Wooble:

30-10-2011 03:51:54 UTC

for

Darknight: he/him

30-10-2011 05:29:24 UTC

imperial

SingularByte: he/him

30-10-2011 07:29:07 UTC

against
As an aside, what happens if there’s an entry in the representation list which isn’t a player? Would it count as two lists (one before the broken entry and one after) or is it still a valid single list?

Josh: Observer he/they

30-10-2011 07:33:33 UTC

against

Moriarty:

30-10-2011 12:13:35 UTC

against

Prince Anduril:

30-10-2011 12:37:40 UTC

against

Ely:

30-10-2011 18:36:48 UTC

against

ChronosPhaenon:

30-10-2011 21:55:11 UTC

My interpretation is that only Amnistar (implictly) and southpoint are represented. Since my name is also mispelled, anything after it is no longer part of the list of Players represented.

Bucky:

31-10-2011 03:30:35 UTC

I interpret it as a single list with an invalid entry that is ignored.  It is patently unreasonable to interpret “ChronosPhaenon” as a delimiter.

(also, my interpretation is nicer when players idle out)

scshunt:

31-10-2011 04:27:44 UTC

I have to agree with Chronos.

Spitemaster:

31-10-2011 04:43:35 UTC

Yeah, because you’re not included.

scshunt:

31-10-2011 04:49:33 UTC

“southpointingchariot, ChronosPhaenon, ais523, Bucky, amnistar, Pavitra, arthexis, Spitemaster, Ienpaw III, Flurie” is not a list of players.

arthexis: he/him

31-10-2011 06:02:52 UTC

I agree with coppro

arthexis: he/him

31-10-2011 18:54:05 UTC

Tally 12-9-1