Saturday, March 27, 2021

Proposal: Death Be Not Proud

Reached quorum 5 votes to 2. Enacted by Kevan.

Adminned at 28 Mar 2021 09:18:35 UTC

Reword the sentence in the rule “Tricks” that reads “If a Player’s Pocket contains a Death, neither the Player or their Opponent may score any points from Tricks” to read

If a Player’s Pocket contains a Death, and their Opponent’s Pocket contains no Ace cards, then neither the Player or their Opponent may score any points from Tricks

Locking down the game for nearly half its duration at a time of your choosing is just too powerful, even without the Arlecchino combo. This nerf allows it to be countered, at a possible cost to your plans.

Comments

Josh: he/they

27-03-2021 16:07:17 UTC

Very excited about nerfing Death rn

Clucky: he/him

27-03-2021 17:24:40 UTC

Not sure this is really the greatest nerf. Aces are very hard to score with, except when scoring Il Vermes, and you can’t score Il Verme if you have an Ace and the other player has death. If anything, this will just allow the death player to score Il Verme while the other player is shut out.

Maybe instead we could limit the shutdown effect of death to only counter the next play?

Clucky: he/him

27-03-2021 17:24:58 UTC

ah I missed the edit window against

Brendan: he/him

27-03-2021 17:47:13 UTC

I considered that, Clucky, but I wanted to try and retain the “if a player’s pocket contains X” framing that is consistent for all the other arcana if possible.

pokes:

27-03-2021 18:51:36 UTC

for too much of a nerf tbh but still better

Clucky: he/him

27-03-2021 18:59:05 UTC

I personally don’t even think its a nerf. will likely result in more games where the death player wins because they can Il Verme due to playing death after their opponent played an Ace (due to having to play an Ace) than lose because their opponent still finds a way to score with the Ace in their pocket.

Josh: he/they

27-03-2021 19:22:21 UTC

for Agree that the nerf can be made chunkier but also agree that making death shorter feels like an uninspired response to the prompt.

Lulu: she/her

27-03-2021 20:04:31 UTC

against per Clucjy

lemon: she/her

27-03-2021 20:18:57 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

28-03-2021 09:17:39 UTC

imperial