I’m not sure that this CFJ is legal – there needs to be a matter that needs urgent attention or an active ruleset disagreement. Did you have one in mind?

yes, I think we should give each Nomicer 3 Jokers, including the idle Nomicer SingularByte.

Also in “Equity” we should replace “Add any way to gain or remove Chips or Jokers, outside of Nomicers spending them to perform game actions.” with “Add any way to gain or remove Disks or Jokers, outside of Nomicers spending them to perform game actions.”

I don’t think that this is a valid CfJ.

Whether it is a valid CfJ or not, I have a preference for “Reverse Equity” over this, starting values of Equity nonwithstanding.

a) in case the CFJ isn’t valid, and b) because I think “Reverse Equity” is a better fix for the same underlying problem. (It’s going to be very hard to determine whether the CFJ is valid or not – there are 10 players, and it’s quite possible that at least one of them thought that something needs urgent attention at the time the CFJ was posted, but we have no way to tell.)

I mean I made the CfJ so that clearly makes it valid, as I can only make the CfJ if I feel there is an urgent matter worth attending too

For my part, I’m not making a judgement on whether or not it’s a CfJ. I’m making a judgement on whether or not it’s urgent enough to bypass the Proposal queue as a CfJ. Clucky so far has not convinced me that it is that urgent.

its not that its urgent enough to bypass the proposal queue, more that my interpretation of the rules indicated we couldn’t update jokers in a standard proposal hence the need for a CfJ

@Clucky: there are rules on when you can make a CFJ, and “this doesn’t work as a proposal” is not one of them.

I personally think that these rules are silly and should be changed, but all my attempts to do so have been voted down (and I have tried multiple times). It is possible that each time, the vote-down was based on other parts of the proposal, but there’s a limit to how often you can reasonably try the same thing.

@ais I’ve been playing this game for 15 years. I know the rules about how CfJs work. I don’t need you to lecture me on them