Wednesday, October 27, 2021

Proposal: Marginalia

Reached quorum, 8-0. Enacted by TyGuy6.

Adminned at 29 Oct 2021 04:43:56 UTC

Add the following as a second paragraph to the rule Whose to Sell?:

The Realtor who posted each Auction is the Auctioneer for that Auction. An Auction’s Auctioneer may not make a Valid Bid on it, although they may undertake Day or Night actions on it. For each Auction, the Reserve is the the sum of the Condition and Appeal of the House being Auctioned. When an Auction Post is closed, if the Top Bid in that Auction was greater than the Reserve, then the Auctioneer gains Bucks equal to the difference between the two.

Comments

Brendan: he/him

27-10-2021 12:27:49 UTC

for

Kevan: he/him

27-10-2021 13:12:05 UTC

for

Trapdoorspyder: he/him

27-10-2021 14:40:49 UTC

for causes a slightly weird interaction with buying traps (which is a night action) but seems good to me.

Vovix: he/him

27-10-2021 16:08:21 UTC

for

TyGuy6:

27-10-2021 16:42:01 UTC

against Two players collaborating could just take every house off the market at Reserve price.

Josh: Observer he/they

27-10-2021 17:26:51 UTC

How? You can only launch one auction every 72 hours

TyGuy6:

27-10-2021 17:48:48 UTC

Ok, then, they could take two houses off the market at Reserve price, every three days. Basically, Auctions converted into two man team snipes, with first come first serve for the best/cheapest houses.

TyGuy6:

27-10-2021 17:50:50 UTC

Which sounds like an interesting mechanic, to be honest, but it’s opaque that that’s what we’re voting for. And I’m sure it wasn’t what was intended.

Josh: Observer he/they

27-10-2021 18:03:44 UTC

I mean, it’s still a somewhat motivated assessment; you yourself have demonstrated that buying houses above the reserve price is a strategy that you can deliberately pursue. Even outside of that strategy there’s almost always a gap between reserve price and likely sale price where a buyer can make a considered profit. This proposal introduces a cost but doesn’t close off that strategy, so portraying it as an avenue to a total lockout is a little mendacious.

Silverwing: she/her

27-10-2021 18:37:39 UTC

for

TyGuy6:

27-10-2021 18:53:18 UTC

men·da·cious
adjective
not telling the truth; lying.

Ok, but fair warning, this will turn the Auction upside down. I’ll go ahead and find a friend to abuse the system with, should this pass.

TyGuy6:

27-10-2021 20:53:53 UTC

Update: Josh was convinced by my explanations in #current_dynasty, and submitted the correction, https://blognomic.com/archive/margin_call, which I can get behind.

Raven1207: he/they

27-10-2021 21:42:12 UTC

for

TyGuy6:

29-10-2021 04:43:04 UTC

imperial CoV