Wednesday, December 21, 2016

Matt uses Well Water on Zaratustra

Doctor, please respond appropriately.

Comments

Kevan: Oracle he/him

21-12-2016 21:08:12 UTC

Note that I’d enacted Well, Well, Well incorrectly, so this action takes effect under the previous wording, and “The target Villager can invalidate this action if they move to another Location within one day; otherwise, the Remedy is removed from the user’s inventory and affects the target as if they had used the Remedy themselves.” (so you get to keep the water until a day has passed).

Kevan: Oracle he/him

21-12-2016 21:22:59 UTC

If you want to retract this action on the grounds that I’d presented a misleading version of the gamestate, I don’t think anyone would argue it. Looks like it shouldn’t make too much difference, though.

Kevan: Oracle he/him

21-12-2016 22:29:26 UTC

Although hmm, now that Well, Well, Well has enacted properly, I’d actually say that this effect fizzles into nothing - the “within one day; otherwise” effect that this legally triggered is no longer a rule, so will no longer happen.

And the “Doctor may respond to such a post” clause can’t be acted upon because no such post, as described by the new rule, has been made while that rule was in effect.

Zaratustra:

22-12-2016 18:39:23 UTC

geeet dunked on