Saturday, September 09, 2017

Proposal: Moving some stuff around

48 hours without reaching popularity. votes 5-6. Failed by derrick

Adminned at 11 Sep 2017 22:06:32 UTC

Move “Combos” and “Tags” under “Core Rules”.

Comments

Darknight:

09-09-2017 22:50:58 UTC

To be fair, I’ve been away awhile so I’m abit unclear about these two rules

Cuddlebeam:

09-09-2017 22:53:06 UTC

I feel like the Core Rules could be getting too huge, for visualization. I’d add it to Appendix. But I agree with the general intent here.

VJRada:

09-09-2017 23:28:08 UTC

These have been left in place for a long time,  for

Sesquipedalian:

09-10-2017 01:22:31 UTC

for

Cuddlebeam:

09-10-2017 01:29:29 UTC

for

pokes:

09-10-2017 02:48:05 UTC

against I like Tags but Combos haven’t been battle tested enough imo.

card:

09-10-2017 04:40:27 UTC

“I’d add it to Appendix.”
a bad idea given the precedence rule. and I agree with pokes here against

Darknight:

09-10-2017 05:32:40 UTC

against

Kevan:

09-10-2017 06:55:15 UTC

against Tags could be merged into an existing core rule, combos still seem a bit rough and underused.

Maldor:

09-10-2017 16:09:30 UTC

against
I wrestled with moving atomic actions into the core rules for a while before actually proposing it, I kinda feel that both of those rules are underused (come to think of it, Atomic actions might be better placed in the appendix…)

Axemabaro:

09-10-2017 19:02:52 UTC

for

derrick:

09-11-2017 11:50:57 UTC

against There are better places to put these rules coming up in the queue.

derrick:

09-11-2017 15:10:08 UTC

NOTE: this does not do anything, as it lacks the tag “[Core]”. This is ironic, to say the least. So those who voted for may want to change their votes.