Wednesday, January 07, 2009

Call for Judgment: Nonsense CfJ = Autofail

Qourumed against.

Adminned at 09 Jan 2009 09:27:52 UTC

At the end of the first paragraph in Core Rule 1.6 add the following,

If a Citizen anonymously posts a nonsense CfJ, that CfJ can be failed regardless of how long its been posted for.

Time to stop this little lemming herd.

Comments

Darknight:

01-07-2009 04:25:43 UTC

for author FOR

Rodlen:

01-07-2009 04:30:12 UTC

What defines a “nonsense” CfJ?

Qwazukee:

01-07-2009 04:37:41 UTC

against Must be more specific, or this power is essentially unlimited (for example, a lot of what BLO does might be considered “nonsense,” and yet all of that is perfectly valid in the game).

Rodlen:

01-07-2009 04:39:27 UTC

against

Darknight:

01-07-2009 04:39:49 UTC

thats why this was aimed at CfJ’s and not proposals. other then that ya I prob should have defined it more

Clucky:

01-07-2009 05:09:36 UTC

against

Amnistar:

01-07-2009 05:11:37 UTC

against  I’d rather it be something like, if the CfJ does not affect the rules or the gamestate it can be auto-failed. or something along this lines.

Yoda:

01-07-2009 06:01:55 UTC

against

Bucky:

01-07-2009 06:02:43 UTC

against .  This should be a proposal.  And even then it’s unnecessary.

Darknight:

01-07-2009 06:05:49 UTC

didn’t wanna burn a proposal spot for something that does need looking at now buck. in any event against

arthexis:

01-07-2009 08:30:50 UTC

foragainst !

Escher:

01-07-2009 18:27:09 UTC

against Yeah, “nonsense” needs to be defined better if you want to make this work.