Call for Judgment: Proper proposte
Popular, 7-0. Josh
Adminned at 05 Mar 2021 20:24:37 UTC
The rule Proposte says
If all the Electors named in the title of a Proposta have the same Secret Faction when the Doge processes it
I’ve not consistently successfully done it that way; I’ve occasionally based the outcome of a Proposte on what the status quo was when it was posted, as that makes more sense to me than a world in which people are allowed to spam Change Secret Faction PMs to me while I’m asleep. Nevertheless, that’s wrong, and it has had a measurable but not, I think, meaningful impact (i.e. I can’t see that Power or Scandal totals would have changed) on the current state of the game.
Rather than unpick a bunch of stuff, uphold the current resolution of all proposte posted before this CfJ, and the Doge will strive to be more consistent.
I think that this rule should be changed though.
Clucky: he/him
Curious to hear from the people effected by this and if they think it is fair