Monday, April 02, 2007

Call for Judgment: Revising Complexity

Quorumed 6-1 -Amnistar

Adminned at 03 Apr 2007 12:57:58 UTC

Hix brought up the possibility of interpreting the Complexity rule as allowing infinite Complexity gain with each proposal.  I think the wording is probably sufficient, but I want to make sure it’s airtight.  This also gives us a chance to revise the rule if we want to take into account alternative methods of obtaining Complexity, to which I’m pretty open.

Replace the text in Lifeform Complexity

For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform’s counted vote on that Proposal had the effect of a FOR vote, e may, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, increase eir Complexity by 1.

With the text XYZ, where XYZ is the text accompanying Axeling’s counted FOR Vote for this CfJ.  Do this replacement only if this text XYZ is found in 3 other counted Votes for this CfJ (minor typographical differences, as determined by the Admin resolving the CfJ, can be ignored for this requirement).  If there is no suitable XYZ, or if it is not found in 3 other counted Votes for this CfJ, do not make any changes to the Rule.

If a Lifeform has gained more than 1 Complexity per Proposal that e is eligible for Complexity gain under Lifeform Complexity, reduce eir Complexity to X, where X is the number of Passed non-Trivial Proposals that e has voted FOR since the introduction of the Rule Lifeform Complexity.

posted by Axeling at 02 Apr 2007 21:22:00 UTC Comments (13)

Comments

ChronosPhaenon:

02-04-2007 22:28:22 UTC

for XYZ = “For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform’s counted vote on that Proposal had the effect of a FOR vote, e may once, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, increase eir Complexity by 1.”

Amnistar: he/him

02-04-2007 22:36:47 UTC

for XYZ= “For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform voted on that Proposal, e may once, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, increase eir Complexity by 1.”

Hix:

03-04-2007 01:02:30 UTC

for XYZ = “For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform’s counted vote on that Proposal had the effect of a FOR vote, e may once, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, increase eir Complexity by 1.”

Axeling:

03-04-2007 01:15:31 UTC

Clucky or anyone else, do you want to introduce something for negative votes?  Otherwise, I will probably just go along with the crowd above.

Seebo:

03-04-2007 01:36:58 UTC

for XYZ = “For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform’s counted vote on that Proposal had the effect of a FOR vote, e may once, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, increase eir Complexity by 1.”

Seebo:

03-04-2007 01:41:09 UTC

against CoV against until axeling makes his post >_<

Hix:

03-04-2007 02:08:44 UTC

against Agreed, don’t want this to fizzle.

Axeling:

03-04-2007 07:38:16 UTC

for For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform’s counted vote on that Proposal had the effect of a FOR vote, e may once, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, increase eir Complexity by 1.

Axeling:

03-04-2007 07:39:12 UTC

Still open to suggestions, if anyone has them, just making the vote so that if it gets passed, we get something at least.

Clucky: he/him

03-04-2007 13:59:34 UTC

for

For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform’s counted vote on that Proposal, e may once, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, roll a DICE3 and increase eir complexity by 1 if e rolls a 3.

Hix:

03-04-2007 15:00:53 UTC

for For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform’s counted vote on that Proposal had the effect of a FOR vote, e may once, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, increase eir Complexity by 1.

Seebo:

03-04-2007 18:01:46 UTC

for For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform’s counted vote on that Proposal had the effect of a FOR vote, e may once, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, increase eir Complexity by 1.

Amnistar: he/him

03-04-2007 19:57:18 UTC

for For each Proposal that is not a Trivial Proposal that is Passed, if a Lifeform’s counted vote on that Proposal had the effect of a FOR vote, e may once, within 48 hours of the Proposal Passing, increase eir Complexity by 1.