Sunday, March 21, 2021

Call for Judgment: Stalled

Fewer than a quorum not voting AGAINST. Failed 0 votes to 5 by Kevan.

Adminned at 21 Mar 2021 15:14:12 UTC

If any Plays have been made in the Fifth Game of Giolitti, between Darknight and Brendan after the posting of this CfJ then it has no further effect.

Add a comment to the Fifth Game of Giolitti, between Darknight and Brendan, stating:

This game is Closed.

That game is now Closed and the Dealer should then post the Fine to the game at their earliest convenience. Make Brendan the Campione of that game as if he had achieved a score of 1 to zero.

Remember when we used to think that six hours was forever

Comments

Kevan: he/him

21-03-2021 09:28:26 UTC

“the Dealer should then post the Fine to the game at their earliest convenience” has no effect, as it updates neither the ruleset nor the gamestate.

Not sure we need this, though. The existing “end games after 24 hours silence” CfJ is at 5-3 with three players (Clucky, Cuddlebeam, Darknight) left to vote. If it fails The Smouldering Cigar will end the Brendan-Darknight game later today, if the queue can be cleared. People should remember to try to vote on everything.

Josh: Observer he/they

21-03-2021 10:06:05 UTC

“the Dealer should then post the Fine to the game at their earliest convenience” has no effect, as it updates neither the ruleset nor the gamestate.

Sure, but it doesn’t need to: making the game closed enables you to do that anyway so at worst it’s superfluous language.

All of the CfJs that have been raised so far have gotten enmired in a tedious wrangle about how many hours is the right number for timing out. My hope is that this one can pass quicker due to more limited effect. If it turns out not to be necessary then so be it, but a sanguine “people should remember to try to vote on everything” is probably insufficient, as they are evidently not.

pokes:

21-03-2021 12:09:37 UTC

against Not a fan of counting it as a win when I got nothing for a draw.

Raven1207: he/they

21-03-2021 14:36:18 UTC

imperial

Darknight: he/him

21-03-2021 14:40:48 UTC

against sorry, I didn’t get any warning prior

Kevan: he/him

21-03-2021 14:56:33 UTC

against Given that Darknight is back and intending to play.

Josh: Observer he/they

21-03-2021 15:02:40 UTC

This now has not effect.  against

Madrid:

21-03-2021 15:12:11 UTC

I idle