Tuesday, April 12, 2011

Call for Judgment: The black sheep of the family passed

Fails at 1-12. -Purplebeard

Adminned at 13 Apr 2011 00:27:43 UTC

I voted on The black sheep of the family before I was a sheep. Thus I believe my vote couldn’t count towards it passing. It passed after I became a player with exactly quorum votes. I believe that The black sheep of the family was erroneously passed by Josh .

If this CFJ passes then The black sheep of the family has not yet passed.

Comments

Josh: HE/HIM

04-12-2011 20:04:08 UTC

against By the time this resolves it will have timed out and be ready for immediate processing anyway. I’ve reverted it’s enactment instead.

Klisz:

04-12-2011 20:07:41 UTC

against on the grounds that The black sheep of the family might actually pass before this does. (Also, you don’t need to make an entire CfJ to correct a mistake; only to settle an actual disagreement.)

spikebrennan:

04-12-2011 20:14:33 UTC

against
because it would result in me having three active proposals in the queue

Darknight: HE/HIM

04-12-2011 20:22:14 UTC

against

Josh: HE/HIM

04-12-2011 20:27:12 UTC

Oh, it’s already resulted in that, spike. Oops ^_^

Bucky:

04-12-2011 20:34:07 UTC

against

ais523:

04-12-2011 20:36:33 UTC

against This sort of thing doesn’t need a CFJ unless there’s actually a controversy, as anyone who can is allowed to update the record of the gamestate to match the actual gamestate

Winner:

04-12-2011 21:09:30 UTC

against

Kevan: HE/HIM

04-12-2011 21:51:50 UTC

against

lilomar:

04-12-2011 21:55:02 UTC

against per ais, everything seems to have been sorted out.
(although, my theory that the best dynasties are the ones that have the most CfJ’s is starting to look like it might apply :P)

udqbpn:

04-12-2011 22:56:58 UTC

against

Roujo:

04-13-2011 00:54:28 UTC

against Per ais523.

Chivalrybean:

04-13-2011 02:13:46 UTC

against