Monday, December 22, 2008

Proposal: Anyone can enact

Timed out, 5 - 1 (with 2 unresolved DEF votes)
Enacted by Elias IX.

Adminned at 24 Dec 2008 14:27:54 UTC

In 2.3 Membership replace the sentence “A Citizen is considered to be idle within each Faction that e doesn’t belong to.” with “A Citizen is considered to be idle within each Faction that e doesn’t belong to, except for the purpose of enacting or failing proposals.”


arthexis: he/him

22-12-2008 19:41:34 UTC



22-12-2008 20:06:45 UTC



22-12-2008 20:10:05 UTC


SingularByte: he/him

22-12-2008 20:33:25 UTC

I’d find it helpful to know the reason for the against and def votes. Is it an objection to admins being able enact proposals that don’t belong to their faction or is it because the rule is ambiguous?

Amnistar: he/him

22-12-2008 21:36:06 UTC


Admins should be able to enact proposals for all the factions.

arthexis: he/him

23-12-2008 00:03:42 UTC

What happens if I say “An admin breaks two bones when e enacts this proposal” or “The admin who enacts this becomes the Watcher”

Amnistar: he/him

23-12-2008 00:37:57 UTC

in the case of the first, nothing, in the case of the second…nothing.

Unless the admin is part of that dynasty.

Here’s one for you though arthexis, what happens if there are no admins in a specific faction?

Amnistar: he/him

23-12-2008 01:09:40 UTC

I’m leaving my vote where it is, because it means faction proposals can be enacted out of order by admins, but since all faction proposals are proposals, there isn’t really nay need for it, because when it reached the end of the queue as a normal proposal it can be enacted.


23-12-2008 17:39:42 UTC


Elias IX:

23-12-2008 20:16:56 UTC



23-12-2008 21:05:29 UTC