Tuesday, April 01, 2025

Proposal: Careful Word Choice

Withdrawn. Failed by JonathanDark.

Adminned at 01 Apr 2025 16:40:55 UTC

In the rule Sins, replace the text

There is a publicly-tracked list of Sins, being a list of words from the EFF Wordlist. The names of Sins are flavour text.

with

There is a publicly-tracked list of Sins. The names of Sins are flavour text, and must be chosen from the possible roll results of the EFF Wordlist.

To prevent pulling from anything but the list itself when making Sins.

Comments

DoomedIdeas: he/him

01-04-2025 04:39:52 UTC

For my ladder combo, I claim the word “in”, with a value of 3 from each of the 3 preceding proposals. “In” appears on the EFF Wordlist page in the banner denoting that the EFF Wordlist is gamestate.

ais523:

01-04-2025 04:45:40 UTC

This appears to be a duplicate proposal (of an earlier proposal that is also named “Careful word choice”) – the only difference is that the blockquotes are linked by “with” rather than “with the text”.

JonathanDark: he/him

01-04-2025 05:46:44 UTC

Josh is likely to label this as trash. Not a good idea to try to throw in near duplicate proposals.

SingularByte: he/him

01-04-2025 05:48:25 UTC

Didn’t there used to be an issue with people accidentally submitting proposals by saving drafts, or something like that? It could be that.

DoomedIdeas: he/him

01-04-2025 06:25:28 UTC

Ah! Yup, I thought I exited out of that one and had to re-type it- when I checked the BlogNomic home page at the time, it wasn’t showing up, so I assumed I had deleted it. My apologies!

DoomedIdeas: he/him

01-04-2025 06:26:08 UTC

against Due to mistaken posting.

ais523:

01-04-2025 06:57:34 UTC

arrow I just realised that the best fix for this situation is to arrow-withdraw the proposal, refunding the slot.

ais523:

01-04-2025 06:58:01 UTC

against Actually no, that doesn’t work – if you arrow-withdraw you’re supposed to submit a corrected version, and we don’t need three copies of this proposal.

ais523:

01-04-2025 06:58:20 UTC

(And I just realised it had been withdrawn anyway.)

Josh: Imperator he/they

01-04-2025 07:21:47 UTC

against Got to trash this, soz

JonathanDark: he/him

01-04-2025 13:25:00 UTC

It’s too bad there isn’t a middle ground in this case.

against