Wednesday, March 18, 2015

Proposal: Changing workplaces

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 23 Mar 2015 14:40:30 UTC

Under rule 2.7 where it says:

...any Townsperson may change that Townsperson’s Workplace to “Home”

add the following:

Any townsperson that has had their workplace changed in this manner, may change their workplace to any other workplace if they wish only once during the season.

It came as a little bit of surprise when I logged on this morning to find myself back working in the home again, and I wondered if their was a better way to change work place then to just change it in the GNDT. Their is currently no way to change the workplace to something either more desireable or more in line with the astrologers reading of the cosmos if someone else sets your workplace to Home, as described in the rule.

Comments

Sylphrena:

18-03-2015 16:47:01 UTC

against because it gives people incentive to wait a long time before choosing their workplace. We may want to increase the grace period, however.

Ely:

18-03-2015 18:07:55 UTC

against because it defeats the purpose of having Acumen and everything.
If missing one’s turn is a concern, we could increase the 24 hours to 36 or 48, or let people choose Workplace before their turn (I personally prefer the latter).

Brendan: he/him

18-03-2015 18:08:21 UTC

I don’t love the 24-hour window, which does sort of go against the whole “no check-in requirement” intention of this Dynasty, but yeah, this solution would completely undo the acumen system.  against

Brendan: he/him

18-03-2015 18:08:42 UTC

I do like that idea, Ely.

mideg:

18-03-2015 18:48:50 UTC

I also like Ely’s idea, although I’d also increase the time some, since with Elys idea AND the 24 hour limit together would make leaving more then 24 hours even more unpredictable…

mideg:

18-03-2015 18:49:00 UTC

Also:  against

Darknight: he/him

18-03-2015 19:10:33 UTC

against

Kevan: he/him

18-03-2015 19:56:53 UTC

against

Maldor: he/him

20-03-2015 02:55:59 UTC

against s/k

Maldor: he/him

23-03-2015 13:55:07 UTC

I would like to remind the Admins that this proposal has been self killed for a few days now