Thursday, February 04, 2021

Proposal: [Core] Fist Eggplant

Times out and fails 1-5. -Bucky

Adminned at 06 Feb 2021 23:33:30 UTC

Change the sentence in the rule “Tags” that reads ‘Votable Matters other than DoVs require the “[Victory]” tag in order to grant victory to an Emperor.’ to read:

Votable Matters other than DoVs require the “[Victory]” tag in order to grant victory to an Emperor; Proposals require the “[Victory]” tag in order to create or update a victory condition in a Dynastic Rule.

Delete the paragraph in the rule “Tags” that begins “If a Votable Matter would make a modification to the rules and it does not…” as well as the list of conditions that immediately follows it.

Bear with me on this, but I think tags should have teeth.

Comments

Josh: he/they

04-02-2021 18:28:04 UTC

This aggrivates me enough that I am unidling to against it (quorum rises to 5)

Bucky:

04-02-2021 18:37:14 UTC

against . Worse than we already have, and worse than eliminating the [Victory] tag entirely.

Clucky: he/him

04-02-2021 18:50:38 UTC

> “Proposals require the “[Victory]” tag in order to create or update a victory condition in a Dynastic Rule.”

Would “Pokes has achieved victory in this dynasty” be allowed without the victory tag under that rule? I’m thinking definitely not.

Would “Any Emperor may delete this paragraph and replace it with the phrase “Pokes has achieved victory” ” be allowed without the victory tag under that rule? I’m thinking… maybe but probably not. It doesn’t create a victory condition. It just creates a condition by which a victory condition could be created.

So scams can still sneak through. Meaning all this does is punish people for forgetting to do the right paperwork

against

Darknight: he/him

04-02-2021 19:59:08 UTC

against

Raven1207: he/they

04-02-2021 23:23:28 UTC

against