Proposal: Criteria are not Effects
Timed out 2 votes to 2. Failed by Kevan.
Adminned at 11 Nov 2023 08:15:14 UTC
In the rule “Achievements”, change
The criteria for an Achievement must be met between the moment just before the first Spell is cast during a Duel and the moment just after the last Spell’s Effects are applied during that same Duel
to
The criteria for an Achievement must be met between the moment just before the first Spell is cast during a Duel and the moment just after the step where Wizards’ Freshnesses are (or would be) reduced during that same Duel
Set the Criteria of the Stargazer achievement to “Have at least two stars more than any other Wizard after all the steps for applying Gewgaws’ effects.”
Set the Criteria of the Blackout achievement to “Have zero stars after all the steps for applying Gewgaws’ effects. “
Set the Criteria of the Perfect Harmony achievement to “Have each personality trait be at least two, and have all of your personality traits be equal, once all the duel’s spells are cast.”
Set the Criteria of the Denied! achievement to “Successfully snipe a spell in a duel where no one but the snipe’s target selected to cast that spell.”
Set the Criteria of the Safe and Sound achievement to “Prevent the loss of at least five stars in the same duel by casting Magical Armor”
If any Achievements have defined Effects, remove those Effects.
Unlocked! used the boilerplate
Add an achievement called “Stargazer” with the effect…
In context, it probably meant criteria rather than effect.
While fixing this oversight, I’m also making a few of the achievements less specific and cleaning up some irreconcilable timing issues where “at the end of the current duel” meant after the achievement check.
cause if the people actually playing want to go with this I don’t want to get in the way
JonathanDark: he/him
“the step for applying Gewgaws’ effects” is ambiguous. There are two steps where Gewgaws are applied:
* Apply the effects of the Duel’s selected Gewgaws, if any, that occur before spells are cast
* Apply the effects of the Duel’s selected Gewgaws, if any, that occur after spells are cast
So you might need to adjust Stargazer and Blackout to reference the second application of Gewgaws.