Monday, October 12, 2020

Call for Judgment: Everlasting Weather

Failed by the passing of another CfJ that failed this one.

Adminned at 12 Oct 2020 16:48:06 UTC

Bais and I had took are turns for the round already but the problem is that the weather was not rerolled to something other than pleasant. I much simpler approach to this that doesn’t mess with the Wiki Page for Great Sea that much would be changing

When an Island Sets the Weather, they randomly select one of the Weather Options which is not the Current Weather. That option becomes the Current Weather.

To

When an Island Sets the Weather, they randomly select one of the Weather Options. That option becomes the Current Weather.


And to Uphold the Set Weather action of turn 5

Comments

Clucky: ABBOT HE/HIM

10-12-2020 00:45:25 UTC

So part of the problem is Josh, as Gaia, is not an Island and so “When an Island Sets the Weather” doesn’t apply

Also no duplicate weather was an intentional design choice, so I’m a bit bummed to lose it but I think you could make the argument that there was no defined way for Josh to generate the weather so either he can’t (and it stays the same) or he defaults to “randomly pick something”

Bais:

10-12-2020 03:03:23 UTC

As in the other CfJ:  Gaia is a special type of island, per the ruleset

Clucky: ABBOT HE/HIM

10-12-2020 03:08:10 UTC

against

Bais:

10-12-2020 07:05:47 UTC

against this CfJ does not fix the Gaia thing;  the other one does

Kevan: HE/HIM

10-12-2020 09:47:02 UTC

against In favour of the other fix that keeps the reduced randomness.

Josh: HE/HIM

10-12-2020 14:23:53 UTC

against