Tuesday, February 23, 2021

Proposal: Family Business

Reaches quorum 7-3, with a little nudge along from Imperial Deferentials. Josh

Adminned at 25 Feb 2021 08:42:01 UTC

In “Factions”, replace “An Elector may change either piece of information at any time,” with

An Elector may change either piece of information at any time to any surname on the [[list of Italian surnames]] wiki page,

For each Elector who has a public Faction which does not appear on the List of Italian surnames wiki page, set that Faction to “-”.

Remove “Italian name” and “Massimo family” from the List of Italian surnames wiki page. (Only noticed these after I’d posted this proposal.)

Comments

Raven1207: he/they

23-02-2021 12:37:12 UTC

for

pokes:

23-02-2021 12:42:34 UTC

against

Kevan: City he/him

23-02-2021 12:47:08 UTC

[pokes] Your “Di Fieri” is on the list, if you hadn’t checked.

Josh: he/they

23-02-2021 13:03:57 UTC

I prefer this change for public Factions, but think secret factions should still be free text (after all, it’s very hard to belong to a family other than the one you overtly belong to).

pokes:

23-02-2021 13:06:36 UTC

@Kevan: Even so, the list of available food puns gets much shorter. Hm.  imperial

Kevan: City he/him

23-02-2021 13:12:30 UTC

[Josh] A lot of these are in practice just Italian nouns - I was intending them to be whispered as nicknames as much as literal family surnames of the player characters. (But having the Capulets as your Secret Faction while you are a Montague would still make plenty of sense, I think: you’re part of one group but privately helping another.)

Lulu: she/her

23-02-2021 13:16:12 UTC

against

Brendan: he/him

23-02-2021 13:40:44 UTC

for

Lulu: she/her

23-02-2021 13:41:54 UTC

for after further thought.  It helps with someone sneaking in a uppercase I into a lowercase l.

Lulu: she/her

23-02-2021 13:42:14 UTC

(And other related things)

Darknight: he/him

23-02-2021 13:52:57 UTC

for

Brendan: he/him

23-02-2021 15:43:12 UTC

I’m going to propose restoring “Italian name” to the list, though.

Clucky: he/him

23-02-2021 16:57:55 UTC

why? this just seems to take away a lot of the creative fun

and the Italian word for Bear is not in the list so

against

Kevan: City he/him

23-02-2021 17:21:20 UTC

“Bears” is in there, it’s “Orsi” (which I guess rules out your Secret Faction, unless that’s a bluff). Throw the page into Google Translate and there are a lot of other animals and nouns.

I think there’s more creative fun to be had within arbitrary constraints. If we want to add a secret assassin faction mechanic to the game later on, deciding to name that group the Lucchetti (“padlocks”) seems at least as enjoyable as calling them “The Assassins Guild” or inventing some other name. A few days of game actions and we’ll all be whispering the name in fear, whatever it is.

Madrid:

25-02-2021 07:59:01 UTC

imperial I unidle

Josh: he/they

25-02-2021 08:41:07 UTC

imperial