Monday, May 16, 2011

Call for Judgment: Go Troll yourself

Reached a quorum 0-10.—Yoda

Adminned at 16 May 2011 16:20:31 UTC

Create a new proposal with the title “Atbiovet” and following text:

Repeal all dynastic rules and start a new metadynasty.

 

Comments

ais523:

05-16-2011 20:48:57 UTC

against A little redundant; you could do this yourself after hiatus ended (after s/king one of your own proposals that’s unlikely to pass) and the timing properties would still be the same.

Yoda:

05-16-2011 20:49:34 UTC

against Why are you proposing to make a proposal?

Josh:

05-16-2011 20:51:57 UTC

He can’t propose because of hiatus.

I am agnostic about the metadynasty idea so won’t be voting. Seems like a bit of a cop-out but if the DoV fails then the status quo is possibly untenable.

Josh:

05-16-2011 20:52:54 UTC

(Is the fact that “metadynasty” is not defined in the ruleset any more a problem?)

Ienpw III:

05-16-2011 20:54:46 UTC

against Because of proposal-cfj weird crossbreed.

But woah.. When Bucky asks for a metadynasty you know things are bad.

Yoda:

05-16-2011 20:55:13 UTC

It still doesn’t make sense because he could just have the CfJ start a new metadynasty if it passes.  Instead, this creates a proposal for a metadynasty, which would not be able to be voted on anyways if we were still in hiatus.

I just don’t understand why he thought it necessary to put the middle man in.

Yoda:

05-16-2011 20:57:26 UTC

Bucky’s just mad because I won without having to bribe him. ;-)

Ely:

05-16-2011 21:02:20 UTC

against Why a proposal?

spikebrennan:

05-16-2011 21:08:22 UTC

against
Let the DoV time out, either way, before taking action like this.

Bucky:

05-16-2011 21:09:35 UTC

@Ely in order to make sure it is interpreted in a humorous light (like the proposal title)

Josh:

05-16-2011 21:09:54 UTC

which would not be able to be voted on anyways if we were still in hiatus

You can do that now.

Klisz:

05-16-2011 21:44:48 UTC

against The word metadynasty hasn’t been defined for a couple years.

Winner:

05-16-2011 22:10:37 UTC

against

Darknight:

05-16-2011 23:01:22 UTC

against

Bucky:

05-16-2011 23:02:36 UTC

against because it’s a joke CfJ

Galtori:

05-16-2011 23:20:04 UTC

against