Saturday, February 18, 2012

Call for Judgment: Invalid Jammer

Times out and passes 4-2 with no penalty.  The Frontman is required to take action.  -Bucky

Adminned at 22 Feb 2012 19:05:02 UTC

Darknight, a Band Member, has invalidly joined the last Jam Session. As a consequence, when the Frontman ended the session, I’ve become aware of Darknight’s style.

To correct this issue, the Frontman must inform me, and anyone else in that Jam Session who was informed of Darknight’s style, if any, the style of a valid Jam Session member.

Also, if more than half the ECVs to this CfJ, contain the text PENALTY X, where X is an integer number, the Frontman will give Darkgnight a random style (which of course may be same as before) and reduce Darknight’s Fame by Y, where Y is the average, rounded down, of all Xs informed in those ECVs.

posted by ChronosPhaenon at 18 Feb 2012 18:34:00 UTC Comments (9)

Comments

ChronosPhaenon:

18-02-2012 18:43:37 UTC

for Explicit vote, PENALTY 0.

Bucky:

18-02-2012 20:32:22 UTC

against PENALTY 0

Cpt_Koen:

18-02-2012 21:05:19 UTC

PENALTY 0
(this is my mistake, not his)

for

I also informed him of the style of one of you.

This is a Call for Judgement, so I’m not allowed to Veto, but if someone tries to abuse it informing a negative X I will make a new CfJ against it.

Clucky: he/him

18-02-2012 21:34:02 UTC

against

Because the penalty crap is unfair to DK. Its Cpt_Koen’s fault, not his. His style shouldn’t have to change.

Kevan: he/him

18-02-2012 22:06:40 UTC

against Because the penalty is unfair and at the time of casting this vote I don’t know whether this CfJ will get a half-quorum of EVCs or not.

Cpt_Koen:

19-02-2012 13:36:59 UTC

for (without the penalty)

Greytyphoon:

19-02-2012 15:31:49 UTC

for (without the penalty)

Josh: he/they

21-02-2012 07:25:33 UTC

for

Cpt_Koen:

23-02-2012 01:34:19 UTC

Rule 1.6 reads “A Pending CFJ may be Resolved by an Admin if it has a Quorum of FOR Votes, a Quorum of AGAINST Votes, or if it has been open for voting for more than 48 hours.”

48 hours is two days; yet this CfJ has been pending for four days and the link under “1 Pending Calls for Judgement” wasn’t read until just now (and I have noticed in my few dynasties here that Calls For Judgement tend to keep pending longer than proposals).

Am I missing some rule about CfJs?