Call for Judgment: Keeping a secret a secret
Timed out 1 vote to 3. Failed by Kevan.
Adminned at 03 Jun 2017 10:00:19 UTC
If upon the enaction of this CfJ, the proposal “Cold (and Hot) War” is pending it is considered to not contain the text “- Sabotage a Camp: Via letting all of the cold flow in and other hijinks, that Camp (and all of its content’s) Temperature lowers by 500 BTU. This action is performed by privately communicating it to the Expedition Leader, along their current Camp (this will be the Sabotaged Camp, even if the Spy move later), and then the Expedition Leader applying the effects as appropriate in a timely fashion.”
If upon the enaction of this CfJ the ruleset contians the text “- Sabotage a Camp: Via letting all of the cold flow in and other hijinks, that Camp (and all of its content’s) Temperature lowers by 500 BTU. This action is performed by privately communicating it to the Expedition Leader, along their current Camp (this will be the Sabotaged Camp, even if the Spy move later), and then the Expedition Leader applying the effects as appropriate in a timely fashion.” then remove that text from the ruleset.
In my opinion, having half of the Backgrounds being secret, as in having it impossible via the game mechanics to reveal beyond a shadow of a doubt the secret Backgrounds is important to keeping the secret roles aspect of the game. Seeing as “Cold (and Hot) War” has a chance of passing due to timing out if Sphinx doesn’t vote at all, I feel the need to make this CfJ. If enacted that proposal will allow someone who is a spy is able to confirm they are a spy via making a specific Camp cold.
Gaelan: