Thursday, September 08, 2011

Proposal: Let’s sweep the deck!

Timed out 1 vote to 5. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 11 Sep 2011 05:07:37 UTC

In the rule “Personal Belongings” replace:

GNDT field “Items”

with

BlogNomic Wiki page “Items”

and in the rule “Salvaging” replace:

GNDT comment field

with

BlogNomic Wiki page “Items”

If the BlogNomic Wiki page “Items” exists, blank it, otherwise create it.
Make an entry for each Survivor and list the items the Survivor possesses.
Delete the GNDT column “Items”.

The GNDT gets a little bit clogged…. If Kevan’s Clue proposal passes, we can think about putting these there, too.

Comments

bateleur:

09-08-2011 20:20:25 UTC

imperial The wording’s a bit unfortunate here, because it blanks the Items page but then adds only an entry for each Item a Survivor possesses. By the time this proposal was enacted it might be the case that one or more Items had been Thrown Off Board and we would then have no record of such an Item’s abilities. (Same applies to Items held by Idling players.)

Kevan:

09-08-2011 22:53:35 UTC

Not sure I follow Bateleur’s objection (since the “Ideas” page remains intact), but I don’t see any problem with the way we’re using the GNDT, either. We have a bit of sidebar for tracking player-related gamestate, and having that being slightly bloated by lengthy item titles doesn’t seem as bad as hiding the whole thing away on a different web page.

against

Florw:

09-08-2011 22:54:18 UTC

imperial

Darknight:

09-09-2011 03:50:04 UTC

against

bateleur:

09-09-2011 06:20:34 UTC

Oh - actually my objection’s invalid. I’d forgotten that our items page is called “Ideas” for some reason!

Prince Anduril:

09-09-2011 07:28:55 UTC

against