add a new Rule to the Ruleset.  Call it “Law of Loss” and give it the following text:

There is an article on the Wiki with the title “The Lost List”.  Any Student whose name appears in this article is Lost.  Lost students have died, gone catatonic, had their soul eaten by demons etc.  The Lost List may only be edited as allowed by subrules of this Rule.

If the Lost List contains any Students’ names when this proposal passes, remove those students names from the Lost List.

I’m thinking later we could add “Lost Students may not achieve victory” or something similar, but it’s too soon to think about victory conditions.