Saturday, September 15, 2012

Proposal: My take at achievemnts tracking

Passes 5-2. 6 EVCs, 2 arrows, IFI not triggered. — Quirck

Adminned at 17 Sep 2012 02:41:30 UTC

If any of the Proposals “A Sense of Achievement”, “Team Work, or Do you actually need a whole GNDT row?”, or “A Sense of Organization.” has passed, this Proposal does nothing.

In the rule “Grading”, change

Rules can cause Students to Score (by saying that the Student Scores) if and only if that Rule has not caused that Student to score earlier in the current dynasty.

to

A Rule can cause a Student to Score (by saying that the Student Scores) if and only if that Rule both:
* has title starting with its unique code in square brackets, the code being three capital english letters;
* has not caused that Student to Score earlier in the current dynasty.

and

When a Student Scores, they gain an Achievement and should brag about it in a blog post.

to

Rules that caused a Student to Score are tracked in the GNDT column named “Scored”. When a Student Scores, they gain an Achievement, and should brag about it in a blog post; and the code of the Rule that caused them to Score shall be added to the list in the “Scored” column.

Rename the rule “Innovations Wanted” to “[IFI] Innovations Wanted”.

I couldn’t come up with a name for the column, so feel free to rename it later.

Comments

IceFromHell:

09-15-2012 13:24:58 UTC

for  arrow
This looks nice to me.

Murphy:

09-15-2012 14:24:08 UTC

arrow  against

Still has things tied to the rules rather than the achievements in them. I like the same-length codes, though; I suggest adding that on top of my named-amendment proposals. (Why “IFI”?)

quirck:

09-15-2012 14:40:04 UTC

I think that it’s a misuse of arrows. This proposal does not introduce anything new.
IFI stands for interesting fresh ideas.

scshunt:

09-15-2012 17:16:41 UTC

against  per Murphy

Josh:

09-16-2012 07:22:29 UTC

imperial

Bucky:

09-16-2012 16:56:21 UTC

for  arrow

Bucky:

09-16-2012 16:56:56 UTC

CoV for  per quirck.

Ely:

09-16-2012 17:11:40 UTC

for