Friday, November 05, 2010

Proposal: Necromancy too advanced

Passes 13-0. —Brendan

Adminned at 05 Nov 2010 22:19:38 UTC

If the Proposal titled “Necromancy too advanced” failed, Thane Q becomes a Ghost instead.

Thane Q becomes a Zombie.

Wee… Okay, so this may be a really bad idea.

Comments

Greytyphoon:

05-11-2010 17:13:25 UTC

for I wanted to vote deferential just to see you reaction. =P
And I prefer zombies to ghosts. (They are easier to control, Mwahaha)

Tuzgai:

05-11-2010 17:15:46 UTC

for Do self-referential proposals work that way?

Klisz:

05-11-2010 17:17:09 UTC

for Though if it fails it just does nothing, so the first sentence has no effect.

FuzzyLogic:

05-11-2010 17:24:01 UTC

for Braaaaaiiiins!

Thane Q:

05-11-2010 17:25:14 UTC

You sure on that, Darth Cliche?

Klisz:

05-11-2010 17:28:33 UTC

Thane Q: Yes, we’ve gone over this sort of thing before you arrived. Long story short, here’s the sentence that makes enacted proposals work:

The oldest pending Proposal may be enacted by any Admin (and the Ruleset and/or Gamestate updated to include the specified effects of that Proposal) if either of the following is true:

(It goes on to have a list of conditions for enactment.)

Here’s the equivalent for failed proposals:

The oldest pending Proposal may be failed by any Admin, if any of the following are true:

No “(and the Ruleset and/or Gamestate updated to include the specified effects of that Proposal)”, therefore no failed proposals having effect. QED.

Thane Q:

05-11-2010 17:36:53 UTC

I see. Well, since I was unaware of this, please forgive me for questioning it. I wasn’t really taking this seriously…

Although, to be honest, I was thinking about self-killing this (and myself) to become a Ghost.

At least it’s relatively harmless, and if people decide to make me a Zombie, I’ll go with it. :)

imperial CoV

Ambisinister:

05-11-2010 17:47:17 UTC

for

Brendan: he/him

05-11-2010 17:53:00 UTC

The obvious exploit otherwise is “If this prop fails, Brendan wins,” and an immediate self-kill.  for anyway.

Kevan: he/him

05-11-2010 17:57:06 UTC

imperial This would be a matter for the Headmaster.

Josh: Observer he/they

05-11-2010 18:18:32 UTC

@Kevan - I’d like to think that, even in our fictional witch school, selection on the basis of race is frowned upon.

Unless it’s governed by zombie Tories?

for

Purplebeard:

05-11-2010 18:55:11 UTC

imperial

Klisz:

05-11-2010 19:27:47 UTC

@Brendan: Or “If this prop fails, add a new rule saying ‘Brendan may edit the ruleset in any way at any time’”, for that matter.

Roujo: he/him

05-11-2010 19:49:06 UTC

for =P

This should prove to be interesting. =)

William:

06-11-2010 00:38:04 UTC

for

Thane Q:

06-11-2010 02:19:26 UTC

for CoV due to School Library proposal.

Darknight: he/him

06-11-2010 03:19:38 UTC

for