Sunday, December 19, 2010

Proposal: Patchwork lego quilt

Reaches quorum and passes, 11-0. Josh

Adminned at 21 Dec 2010 01:02:18 UTC

If the Proposals titled “Hard Hats” or “Grab bag!” failed, this Proposal does nothing.

Enact the effect of the proposal titled “Grab Bag!”, ignoring the contingent on rule “Hard Hats” and replace “In the rule Hard Hats, after” with “In the rule Currency, after”.

Comments

Subrincinator:

12-19-2010 20:00:12 UTC

imperial

iqforu:

12-19-2010 20:06:27 UTC

imperial

Klisz:

12-19-2010 20:57:51 UTC

imperial This could set a dangerous precedent, so I’ll leave it to Josh since he’s been around forever.

Darknight:

12-19-2010 21:35:50 UTC

o.0

Clucky:

12-19-2010 21:41:09 UTC

Why is it dangerous? Its the exact same thing as re-proposing word for word, (modulo the phrasing at the start) but does it better.

for

Josh:

12-19-2010 22:18:57 UTC

Arg, I don’t want the pressure.

I would have voted for anyway.

Hyronious:

12-19-2010 22:28:43 UTC

for

Klisz:

12-19-2010 22:32:37 UTC

Clucky: Hmm. It seems I’ve misread it as something along the lines of retroactively changing the proposal content.

for CoV

iqforu:

12-20-2010 00:32:36 UTC

for

iqforu:

12-20-2010 00:33:04 UTC

Sorry, disregard last post. Already voted.

William:

12-20-2010 03:32:03 UTC

for

scshunt:

12-20-2010 04:58:01 UTC

for

Josh:

12-20-2010 07:36:14 UTC

Although this does make a bit of a mess. While the main bulk of Grab Bag does nothing, the clauses that affect sub-rules (“Flat bricks” and “Bricks”) will still enact with that proposal, and will be duplicated if this passes as well. We’ll just have to propose to get rid of the redundancy.

Thane Q:

12-20-2010 07:59:00 UTC

Didn’t consider that. My mistake. Oh well.

Roujo:

12-20-2010 15:22:20 UTC

for

Clucky:

12-20-2010 18:28:53 UTC

No Josh, the proposal says “If the rule Hard Hats doesn’t exist, this proposal does nothing”.

The rule “Hard Hats” doesn’t exist. So the proposal does nothing. Even the two later clauses do nothing. So there will be no redundancy.

Ambisinister:

12-20-2010 20:54:55 UTC

for