Thursday, February 09, 2012

Proposal: Power Play

Self-killed. Failed by Kevan.

Adminned at 13 Feb 2012 06:02:01 UTC

Add a new dynastic rule called “Showing Off” and give it the following text

A Band Member may choose to Show Off by sending a PM to the Frontman. That Band Member is considered to be Showing Off until they cease to be a Band Member or the ruleset states otherwise.

In the rule “Fame” replace

if all Band Members have the same style, the Frontman must first increase the Fame of each of the Band Members by C where C is the number of Band Members, divided by two, rounded up and then reassign each Band Member a new style via the process used for new Musicians. All Band Members then become Hangers On

with

if all Band Members have the same style, then if there is exactly one Band Member who is Showing Off the Frontman must increase that Band Member’s Fame by B where B is the number of Band Members. Otherwise, Frontman must increase the Fame of each of the Band Members who is not Showing Off by C where C is the number of Band Members, divided by two, rounded up. In either case, all Band Members then become Hangers On (and thus cease to be Showing Off)

Makes it a game of chicken as well. If just one guy shows off, they get twice the fame and everyone else is hosed. But if someone else shows off they bounce and none of the showoffs get any fame.

Comments

Murphy:

09-02-2012 22:14:29 UTC

for

ChronosPhaenon:

09-02-2012 22:20:55 UTC

imperial

PBURNS:

09-02-2012 22:30:21 UTC

for Pretty sure there’s some type of prisoner’s dilemma involved here, but I haven’t quite worked it out yet. I like the extra little complexity.

Spitemaster:

09-02-2012 22:48:16 UTC

for

Greytyphoon:

09-02-2012 22:56:03 UTC

Too easy to set yourself as “Showing off” and attempt harmony right after.
There should be a way to stop Showing Off by simply sending a PM to the Frontman, no?

——

I was proof-reading, and realised that you removed the “random reassignment” of style. I was going to vote deferential, but that changes my vote to against

Clucky: he/him

10-02-2012 01:07:07 UTC

whoops. the style thing was certainly a mistake. good catch against

Although at your other point… “showing off” is intentionally *not* tracked in the GNDT just like style. So one of the other band members might’ve already decided to show off. You have no way of knowing.

Bucky:

10-02-2012 01:11:54 UTC

imperial

Bucky:

11-02-2012 21:14:42 UTC

CoV against