Friday, December 03, 2010

Call for Judgment: proposal admined out of order

Times out and fails at 1-9. -Purplebeard

Adminned at 07 Dec 2010 07:16:59 UTC

The Proposal: Domus Meus ( http://blognomic.com/archive/domus_meae/ ) was admined while some older proposals are still pending.
According to Rule “1.5 Resolution of Proposals” it couldn’t have been enacted because it wasn’t the oldest pending Proposal.

De-enact the Proposal if it’s possible

As the Proposal does not really depend on previous pending proposals, another option is to somehow mark it as “erroneously admined”, wait for the older proposals to cease being pending and re-enact the Proposal.

Comments

SethOcean:

03-12-2010 10:10:01 UTC

Oh ... and the Proposal: Ruleset Accuracy fix (Core proposal) ( http://blognomic.com/archive/ruleset_accuracy_fix_core_proposal/ ) was also admined (failed) out of order.

Josh: he/they

03-12-2010 10:52:38 UTC

against If something has been done illegally you can just revert it (or point it out to an admin for reversion) - no need for a CfJ which can take days to resolve.

I shall revert now but this should still fail, as both proposals will inevitably have timed out by the time this resolves.

Roujo: he/him

03-12-2010 12:48:29 UTC

against Per Josh.

SethOcean, I’d dub your CfJ-Man if another player didn’t already go by the alternate nickname CallForJudgement. =P

Alecto:

03-12-2010 13:22:02 UTC

against

scshunt:

03-12-2010 13:45:35 UTC

against

scshunt:

03-12-2010 14:32:09 UTC

My apologies, btw

ais523:

03-12-2010 15:21:40 UTC

I’m glad someone’s finally paying attention to this sort of thing! (Pointing it out in a post is generally better, though; CfJs are mostly useful for if there’s either a dispute, or if the gamestate’s become gamebreakingly broken or mathematically impossible (positive numbers defaulting to zero, anyone?)

Kevan: City he/him

03-12-2010 16:33:41 UTC

against

Brendan: he/him

03-12-2010 17:21:24 UTC

against

Purplebeard:

03-12-2010 17:50:03 UTC

against

Ambisinister:

04-12-2010 04:07:30 UTC

against

Darknight: he/him

04-12-2010 04:17:25 UTC

against

lilomar:

04-12-2010 19:34:58 UTC

against

Blacky:

07-12-2010 10:40:23 UTC

against