Could lead to a slightly unsustainable Achievement inflation, especially when combined with a potential reward for Most Proposals. I think at this stage it would be better to come up with Achievement rewards for dynastic mechanics rather than meta-play.

I actually think it won’t happen much at all, but I like the idea.

.  Round 3 for this rule?

personally think achievements should be harder to get, but willing to defer to bucky on that

I’m sorry, doesn’t Bucky’s first proposal say you can only use each rule to score once? So there’s only one flavor point available for each player ever. That should prevent inflation.

Yes, you’re right. 

This could turn into a group of people agreeing to ‘up arrow’ each others’ proposals whilst denying arrows to the minority not in the group. Thus, a slight majority may drastically increase its chances of taking the Dynasty my eliminating a large minority from contention.

On the other hand, a slight majority can take eliminate a large minority from contention at any point during the game, so this rule would do little to further enable a majority.

oh, also,