Saturday, December 20, 2008

Proposal: Taking Rodlen WAY too seriously

Sealed imperially—Rodlen

Adminned at 21 Dec 2008 08:37:35 UTC

Make the Citizen Darth Cliche an Admin.

Comments

Rodlen:

20-12-2008 02:49:32 UTC

for

Klisz:

20-12-2008 02:51:02 UTC

Wait, what? I thought you were joking when you suggested it in the other post

Rodlen:

20-12-2008 02:52:40 UTC

We can always use more admins.

arthexis: he/him

20-12-2008 02:55:47 UTC

for For now.

Klisz:

20-12-2008 02:57:35 UTC

Hmm.

Klisz:

20-12-2008 03:01:28 UTC

Vote Darth Cliche for Admin!

eljefe:

20-12-2008 03:03:01 UTC

for

Darknight: he/him

20-12-2008 03:11:50 UTC

for

Sgeo:

20-12-2008 03:25:58 UTC

imperial

Bucky:

20-12-2008 03:26:37 UTC

against

Klisz:

20-12-2008 03:26:46 UTC

Me - For
Rodlen - For
arthexis - For
eljefe - For
Darknight - For

5 more votes and 11.5 more hours, and I’m an admin.

Clucky: he/him

20-12-2008 03:28:02 UTC

against

Klisz:

20-12-2008 03:28:30 UTC

Posted that at the same time as Sgeo and Clucky. I have a bad habit of doing things like that.

Klisz:

20-12-2008 03:29:21 UTC

Oops, meant to say Bucky in the last post. And I did it again.

Klisz:

20-12-2008 03:29:55 UTC

Bucky and Clucky, what are your reasons?

Bucky:

20-12-2008 03:44:07 UTC

Maturity.  In general, it takes new players a couple of dynasties to get used to how things work around here.  It varies by player, but I get the impression that you haven’t hit the critical level of experience yet.

Amnistar: he/him

20-12-2008 03:44:16 UTC

against

Nothing personal Darth, I just haven’t played with you for awhile.  After this dynasty if you still want to be an admin, I’m sure I’ll be mmore than willing to vote for you.

Klisz:

20-12-2008 03:46:55 UTC

I understand and accept your reasons. I assume Clucky’s reason is because of the PM about Rodlen’s plans I sent all active players earlier.

Amnistar: he/him

20-12-2008 03:50:30 UTC

Going to include in mine a lack of familiarity about the rules.  Admins need to be very aware of the core rules, especially those pertaining to proposals.  A lack of awareness about how they work is not a bad thing, just not something that is condusive to being an Admin.

Klisz:

20-12-2008 03:51:53 UTC

You know, this proposal was mainly a joke anyway, since Rodlen jokingly suggested that I should become an admin after finding out that some bug in EE is letting me use the admin function.

Darknight: he/him

20-12-2008 03:59:30 UTC

against

Klisz:

20-12-2008 04:17:57 UTC

against s/k.

Klisz:

20-12-2008 04:19:34 UTC

against s/k.

Yoda:

20-12-2008 06:09:47 UTC

You know, I was actually made an admin in the same dynasty in which I joined.

Klisz:

20-12-2008 06:13:12 UTC

Quorum was probably low back then.

Yoda:

20-12-2008 06:27:07 UTC

Actually, it went about 100 hours before finally being enacted.  In that time, I think it went back and forth between passing and failing about 3 or 4 times, and quorum was probably around 7 or 8 (not too high but not too low).

Yes, I did make some mistakes early on (like adminning proposals too early), but I learned from my mistakes.  As such, I say that if DC really wants to be an admin, let him.  I think that the only reason you should disallow someone from becoming an admin is if you honestly believe that they would abuse it.

Klisz:

20-12-2008 17:25:50 UTC

To quote myself:
“You know, this proposal was mainly a joke anyway, since Rodlen jokingly suggested that I should become an admin after finding out that some bug in EE is letting me use the admin function.”

I don’t see much of a use for actually being an admin, besides speeding everything up.

To quote myself again:
against s/k.”

Rodlen:

21-12-2008 16:36:53 UTC

veto The Veto of Doom!!!