Tuesday, September 12, 2017

Call for Judgment: The Katamari’s Stability is 1

Reached Quorum 8 to 0. Enacted by Derrick.

Please let me know if you subtracted multiple stamina and I missed you in the update.

Adminned at 13 Sep 2017 13:57:27 UTC

The wiki page titled “The Katamari” has been updated to list the Katamari’s Stability as first 3, and then later 4. Axemabaro has also paid 3 Stamina on two recent occasions to Push the Katamari.

As far as I’m aware, the only proposal which contained a mechanism that could increase Stability was “Proposal: Theft”, which said:

If the rule Not Always Quite Round exists, then the text of this rule includes:

In addition, the Katamari’s Stability is increased by one.

This is not reflected in the wiki page titled “Ruleset”, presumably because no rule “Not Always Quite Round” existed when the proposal was passed. (The intent of the proposal was apparently that this clause would take effect if the proposal titled “Not Always Quite Round” had passed, but said proposal did not create a rule with the same name.)

Even if such a rule were in effect, no Thefts have taken place according to my reading of the GNDT, and so Stability would still be 1.

Therefore:

- Update the wiki to reflect that the Katamari’s Stability is 1.
- Update GNDT as necessary to reflect the correct cost for Pushes.

Not sure if a CfJ is the correct response to this situation, but it seemed like the fallback for confusion, and I’m currently confused. :)

Comments

Cuddlebeam:

09-12-2017 20:29:28 UTC

Oho, very good catch Semiel.

for

card:

09-12-2017 21:03:28 UTC

for

Kevan:

09-12-2017 21:51:52 UTC

for

VJRada:

09-12-2017 21:56:54 UTC

for

Darknight:

09-12-2017 22:17:55 UTC

for

Semiel:

09-12-2017 22:23:59 UTC

for

Sesquipedalian:

09-12-2017 23:05:40 UTC

for

derrick:

09-13-2017 13:56:10 UTC

for